'Bee Lines' exhibition

Bee Lines is a new work by Alice Forward: the site09 Darbyshire award winner (*). I was fortunate to go to the preview yesterday afternoon at SVA, 4 John Street, Stroud. Well worth a look in to see...

Photos: from the exhibition - starting with a giant varroa mite!

Exhibition dates: 27th February-14th March: Tuesday-Saturday 10am-3pm, Sunday 11am-1pm - see more details at: www.sva.org.uk

Before saying more about the exhibition I ought to mention Jesse Jowers of the Global Bee Project has a talk about bees with the Stroud Valleys Project this Thursday - phone SVP to see if any places left.

Anyhow here's what the press release says: ‘BEE LINES is a show of new sculpture, drawing and video which, according to the artist “is a series of ongoing explorations around the ambivalences in our relationship with the natural world, and about ideas of territory.” Following a period of fascination by and research into the history and philosophy of map-making, manifesting itself recently in the form of intensely fine pencil rubbings, a more recent interest; mans relationship with the honey bee, has found a place in Forward’s work. The artist cites the migration of plants, empire building, colonisation and the use of both maps and bees as symbolic tools as significant themes within her work.

A new project called BEE-LINE1 will also be launched as part of the exhibition. Two purpose-built beehives will feature and at the end of the exhibition these will be pressed into the making of a ‘Bee Line’ between Stroud and Bristol, helping to promote links between both places as well as highlight the worldwide importance of all pollinators. Documentation of the setting up and fortunes of the hives will take place and can be seen on the BEE LINES website.

I did get a chance to talk to the artist briefly - but was in such a rush that only got a chance to talk about plans for Stroud to become the first Bee Guardian town rather than hear more about the exhibition.

Born and brought up in Johannesburg, South Africa, Alice Forward studied fine art at Hornsey School of Art in London before training in documentary film-making and freelancing for BBC Television, ultimately returning to independent practice. Following further studies, directorships and setting up of initiatives, she won the Darbyshire Award in 2009, before taking part in the AIM Biennale in Marrakech and doing an artist residency at Joya, Andalusia. She is currently based at BV STUDIOS, Bristol.

BEE LINES Associated events

Photo: Poisoned bee by Alice Forward

Sunday 7 March 11am In conversation with Alice Forward and Tom Trevor, director of Arnolfini
Sunday 14 March 11am Talk by Paul Hand, Beekeeper specialist

(*) As the winner of the Site Darbyshire award, Alice Forward was offered an exhibition at Stroud Valleys Artspace (SVA) and the manufacture of new work from Darbyshire Framemakers. Beyond the presentation of a cheque, the award offers a mentoring service from Mark Darbyshire and SVA in the form of a dialogue with the winner, in order to realize work which previously could only have existed at the proposal stage. Darbyshire has quickly established itself as a leading framer and art fabricator,providing creative solutions through a process of collaborative consultation. This belief in creative collaboration has been at the heart of much of Darbyshire's work, and has attracted a range of high-profile clients; artists like Damien Hirst and Tracey Emin, commercial galleries such as Gagosian and White Cube, and public museums such as the Serpentine Gallery and the Royal Academy, as well as numerous private collectors including Charles Saatchi.

The Darbyshire Award was awarded to Alice Forward for her piece ‘Gold Label’, shown at the Museum in the Park as part of the exhibition of work by shortlisted artists. Forward transformed a puddle of her own urine on steps outside the museum into gold by drawing around it and laying gold leaf on top. Laden with social and historical references as well those as mark-making, poetry and alchemy, Forward says of the work; “it’s about playing around with ideas of status and prejudice.”

Hedgehog Hospital at Bussage Village Hall on Saturday

Well regular blog readers will remember several blogs regarding the new Hedgehog Hospital in Brimscombe - well their website has more info: www.helpahedgehog.org/

They have also now rescued over 50 hedgehogs and returned them to the wild - 14 juveniles are also now successfully gaining weight so that they can be released very soon. You can find out more on Sat 6th March at Bussage Village Hall from 1-3pm where there will be a cake and coffee sale to raise money - plus new membership packages and a sponsor a hedgehog scheme.

Guest Blog: Whiteshill and Ruscombe Pancake races

My report on the recent pancake races is here with photos - but below is the official report with the official results, just published, written by organiser, Tracey Brian. Thanks again to her for all the work and of course the Village Shop for all their support and delicious pancakes.

Photos: me running with twisted ankle now nearly repaired (I hope) and below Juniors race participants and the gents race photo call at the bottom.

The Results !!! Sat 13/02/10 Whiteshill Playing Field

Whilst Team GB were preparing for the 1st day of the Winter Olympics in Canada, there we all were – gathered on a cold February morning on the playing field in Whiteshill, frying pan in hand, limbering up for what has become a major part of the social / sporting calendar for the area. We started with 18 children and their sporting adults, with more arriving during the races.

The weather was a sharp contrast to last year’s race day when we were virtually sunbathing, but at least we were free from the snow and ice that we had become accustomed to this year and at least the sun did emerge later on.

Photographers from both the Stroud News & Journal and the Citizen arrived to capture the event for posterity and we forgave the television companies lack of attendance since their attention was more focused on the other great athletes across the sea.

The juniors set the standard with their race – won by 8yr old Daisy Mason of Whiteshill.!

Not to be outdone by the neighbouring village, 5 year old Alex Vale of Ruscombe won the infants race, with the only girl – Whiteshill’s 5yr old Ella Clissold coming a respectable 3rd.

A couple of youngsters drop out – possibly concerned about the serious competition, but the Infants gamely agreed to join 4yr old Alfie Selway in the Pre-school race. However the swift-footed Alfie from Ebley was always the favourite to win this race. Possibly due to a “handicap” being imposed upon the Infants who had to hop and jump as well as running and tossing their pancakes

Then it was time for the race that everyone had been waiting for – the adult men. Well, what can we say – the rules had to be repeated several times – if only to ensure no injuries were incurred via foul play and the fact that they are the biggest cheats out (allegedly). One gentleman, who shall remain nameless, but has an affinity with the colour green (sorry Philip!!), even tried to obtain an unfair advantage by claiming an ankle injury (no sick note was forthcoming though !). Competition was fierce and the fame of these annual races had not only reached Tuffley but had spread as far as the great metropolis of Oxford ! Needles to say winning Ruscombe runner and flipper – Russell Vale, soon put pay to foreign competition and sent his brother limping back to Oxford after thrashing him intro 4th place!

Not to be outdone, the ladies then lined up on the starting line, armed with their frying pans and were soon flipping and racing across the football pitch in search of glory. Gents beware, they looked a mean bunch and brandished their pans in a most menacingly manner! At the other end, Kate Selby came out triumphant and unscathed.

The races were followed by presentation of the certificates and prizes and photo-shoot.

Multi-tasker Angie Mason (Mrs Mason to her friends!!) turned lineswoman and photographer for the event – so many thanks to her.

Thanks also to the friends and families who turned up on a cold morning to support the races and enjoy pre and post-race pancakes and other delights in the cosy village shop.

The event would not be possible without the wonderful village shop volunteers led by Mary Watkins who not only provided “racing pancakes” but produced pancakes with delicious fillings, cakes, snacks and drinks. They were certainly kept busy by the race participants and supporters.

We all now look forward to the Easter event at the shop and of course have only 2 years to prepare for the Pancake Olympics in 2012.

Infants race
1st = Alex Vale (5yrs)
2nd = Nathan Martin (6yrs)
3rd = Ella Clissold (5yrs)
4th = Joe Mason (5yrs)

Ladies race
1st = Kate Selby
2nd = Caroline Vale
3rd = Angie Mason

Juniors race
1st = Daisy Mason (9yrs)
2nd = Lisa Christensen (9yrs)
3rd = Grace Briggs (9yrs)

Pre-school race
1st = Alfie Selway (4yrs)
With a very big thank-you to the “Infants” who joined in with Alfie & gamely hopped & jumped to make it a bit fairer for our pre-schooler !!

Gents race
1st = Russell Vale
2nd = Adam Martin
3rd = Philip Booth
4th = Duncan Vale

The Randwick Community Plan: get involved!

Well the Randwick Community Plan is out and a report has just been completed as a 'Gloucestershire Parish and Community Led Plan Case Study'.

Photo: Revealled for the first time on this blog: my favorite seat in Randwick.

The report is available with photos on the Randwick Parish site here with a copy of the full plan to download. However I have also included the text below as it gives some important info - I also start with a quote about it from myself urging participation...

"This Community Plan has been created by consultation and meetings with many local groups, the views of 50% of Randwick households responding to surveys, and particularly the hard work of volunteers like Richard Huxford and Calvin Williams. The Plan highlights community needs and celebrates what's good in our community. It sets out a vision that we can all play a part in realising. Already much has been achieved. Work continues on developing a Parish Design Statement that will play an important role in shaping local future developments. A Parish Environmental Survey is also planned. The Action Plan also needs reviewing, revising and updating annually. There is much residents can engage with - do contact me if you want to help be part of building our community." Philip Booth, Stroud District Councillor for Randwick, Whiteshill and Ruscombe

Randwick Parish Plan

Completion Date: 2006. Population: 1402

Compiled by Gloucestershire Rural Community Council (GRCC): Randwick Community-Led Action Plan Case Study

Interviewees for this piece: Richard Huxford (Chairman, Randwick Parish Council) and Calvin Williams (Chairman, Randwick Parish Plan Group).

Background

Randwick parish lies high up on a south-facing slope of the Cotswold escarpment overlooking the Frome Valley to the west of Stroud. It is evident from prehistoric earthworks in the woods above the village that humans have long been active in the area but the first recorded reference to Randwick dates only from the late 11th. Century, at which time it lay in the parish of Standish and belonged to Gloucester Abbey.

From the 17th. to the 19th. Century the parish became very fragmented and widely dispersed, with 42 elements scattered as far afield as Moreton Valence and the River Frome. Most residents were engaged in agriculture or the cloth industry, either within the parish or close by. During the decade leading up to 1894 when civil parishes were established as the lowest tier of the new local government system, Randwick parish became a single compact area, with the majority of inhabitants living in dwellings to the north east of St John's Church. Apart from small communities at Westrip, Humphries End and Townsend, most other dwellings in the parish were isolated. The population then was said to be about 500.

Thus at the start of the 20th. Century the parish comprised four main groups of stone cottages, with further individual dwellings scattered along the road leading from Ebley to Edge, which runs through the middle of the parish. Lower down the slope, most of the land was used for agriculture or as orchards. Within the parish were three public houses, one church, three chapels, a school, post office, several shops and a number of local tradesmen.

Little significant change took place until public utilities had been widely introduced in the middle of the Century. However, that innovation coupled with the national house-building programme that followed the second World War, changed the parish markedly. Much of the former agricultural land to the south of the village was progressively given over to housing and by 1960 the population had risen to 830, few of whom were employed within the parish. To satisfy the growing need for a community meeting place, a village hall was built, largely by public subscription in 1964.

Meanwhile, national fears about potential loss of the rural landscape had been growing. In 1931, the National Trust had acquired Standish and Randwick Woods, with the aim of protecting them from development. In 1966 the Cotswold Area of Outstanding Natural Beauty was established and the older parts of Randwick fell within it. In 1990 the ANOB was extended, so the only parts of the parish not included were the southern areas of housing built after World War II. Finally, in 1990 the Randwick Conservation Area was established.
Following the building programmes of the 1960s and 70s no further major developments were undertaken, but several in-fill areas of housing have been completed. Over the intervening years general social changes have had their effect, with the result that within the parish there are now only 2 public houses, no chapels, no post office, no shops and fewer tradesmen. However, a second primary school has been built within the parish to accommodate the post war population growth. In 2004 there were officially 623 households and a population of 1402, which has since remained fairly static.
What is a Community-Led Plan? A Community Led Plan is a document that sets out a vision for a community future based on sound local research looking at social, environmental and economic life. It celebrates positive features and activities, highlights community needs and contains a detailed action plan to help the community meet those needs. Community led plans are produced by and for communities, based on a detailed survey and consultation process which involves the whole community, prompts action and influences others. Good community plans, use the Community Led Planning Toolkit framework, are supported by external facilitators and can demonstrate a robust evaluation process that ensures their quality.

The Process

It was agreed by the Parish Council after preliminary discussions with GRCC to develop a Parish Plan and to apply for funding to help make it happen. An open meeting was held to introduce the concept of a plan to the parish, to explain how it would benefit the parish, its possible scope and the need for widespread consultation and involvement beyond the workings of the Parish Council. This preliminary meeting was well attended by over seventy parishioners. As a result of the support the Parish Council decided to go ahead and a second open meeting was held when a similar number of parishioners attended The Parish Council strongly advocated the view that the Parish Plan should be led from hereon by a strong "independent (of the PC) community champion" as Chairman of the Parish Plan Steering Committee and such a person was duly elected at this meeting. Also at this meeting we sought views regarding aspects of parish life under key headings which became consistent throughout the process. These headings were:
1) Natural Environment - Green spaces, footpaths, walks & access to the countryside, wildlife, noise and air pollution
2) Built Environment - housing roads & traffic, village design
3) Social & Leisure - education leisure facilities employment
4) Services - transport facilities and community buildings

During the meeting we also recruited a number of volunteers, in three categories - those interested in being on the steering committee, those interested in being in an interest group (focusing on one of the four key areas and those willing to help out "as and when'" or with a specialist skill such as photography, design or analysis, etc.

At this point we had no idea as to what form the planning process would take as we were keen that as many people as possible should have an input in the way that consultation would take place. Indeed this became the subject of a further open meeting with those people who had volunteered to become involved. Out of this meeting a consensus was reached that a parish survey would be undertaken with every household receiving a questionnaire and after that key groups of people would be interviewed to add additional context to the parish survey findings. Interest groups were formed and asked to come up with 10 questions each under their subject headings, which would form the basis of the questionnaire. Over a series of weeks these were debated and a final form of the questionnaire was constructed which, it was felt, covered all the areas we could possibly influence within the plan. Subject areas such as the future of the schools and churches were felt to be beyond our sphere of influence and were therefore not included. Volunteers delivered and collected the questionnaires and all the answers were collated. Approximately 50% of households responded. The final phase of the project was to confer with other specific groups who might not be catered for in the questionnaire.


These groups were as follows:
a) Senior citizens
b) Youth Groups
c) Businesses or people employed within the community
d) Sports groups

From the consultations a prioritised Action Plan was drafted and finalised after several revisions as a result of consultation within the parish and with outside agencies like SDC, GCC, GRCC etc. and links with 31 other external agencies. Finally the whole process was formally adopted by the Parish Council and then published as an official document with copies lodged with various external agencies and locally for reference as well as on the parish website. In addition, a Digest of the parish plan, covering some of the key points arising out of the consultation and which now appear in the Action Plan were also produced (together were a parish map and contacts directory) and delivered to every household in the parish. The digest was subsequently included in a new residents welcome pack provided by church volunteers.

What are your achievements as a community to date?

Natural Environment
* Established post of Part Time Parish Handyman for general maintenance, grass clearing, cleaning bus shelters and planned programme of litter clearance, etc.
* Appointed volunteer Parish Watercourse Warden to monitor the streams ponds and watercourses in Randwick.
* Strengthened the links between the Parish Tree Warden etc and SDC & GCC Tree wardens over issues of tree preservation and public safety e.g. In the Well Leaze
* Identified and improved specific stiles and footpaths within the parish and encouraged the use/replacement of Cotswold stone walls where possible
* Began annually phased programme of providing additional dog-waste bins and salt bins in selected areas of the parish. These needs were identified in the Parish Plan and in consultation with parishioners and involved liaising with outside agencies e.g. SDC and GCC Highways.

Built Environment
* Completed Phases 1 & 2 of a major phased refurbishment & development of the Village Hall to increase and enhance its facilities and usage and reduce its carbon footprint
* Following extensive consultation introduced a voluntary "20 is Plenty" scheme and other traffic calming measures across parish with the appropriate signage as a first phase towards obtaining mandatory 20mph status
* Trialling a scheme to reduce light pollution and energy use between midnight & 5.30am by turning off selected street lighting.

Social & Leisure
* Permanently adopted the experiment of holding Parish Council meetings in different venues and locations across the parish to attract wider community involvement and access as well as a routine Public Forum agenda slot.
* Continued financial provision for parish sporting and community groups e.g. Village Hall & Playing fields Committee, Cricket Club & Brownies etc. with grant criteria based on Parish Plan outcomes
* Ongoing consultation with leisure groups on the redevelopment of the Guide Hut

Services
* Improved Parish Council communications e/g developed Parish Website and Notice Boards to publicise Standing Orders & Financial Regulations, Agendas, Minutes, Reports, etc, monthly "Notes" in Randwick Runner (the weekly parish newsletter) with regular features on Energy Saving & Recycling - tips etc.
* Provided a third notice board within the parish
* Improved liaison with Police, National Trust, GCC Highways and Neighbourhood Watch over parish issues including inappropriate use dumping, improved access, cold calling, etc.
* Major update of the Randwick Parish directory and consequently of mirrored information on the village website.

Randwick Village Hall? The Village Hall development stands as a major achievement in its own right, impacting positively across the four main areas. The consultation outcomes from the Parish Plan provided a clear mandate for improvements and gave the project leaders the foundations for the Village Hall Development Plan as well as key content to include in a range of funding applications. Some of the detail of community aspirations for the facility translated directly in to the Hall Plan and subsequent successes. Funding applications have benefited tremendously from the Parish Plan research and consultation; although unsuccessful it was a specific requirement in the Lotteries application and it was vital to successful applications to other trusts and the local authority.

How has the Randwick Community Plan helped you to engage with your local authority about services your community needs? Randwick Parish Plan has been a major factor in strengthening our relationship with all tiers and departments of our local authorities and other external agencies, stakeholders, etc. The Action Plan itself identified a range of specific actions or issues requiring direct liaison with 31 external agencies. Our links with Planning Officers, Highways Dept, Police, National Trust, Stroud Valleys Project, Severn Wye Energy, Cotswold Way, Severn Trent, etc. have all benefited and gained credibility from having issues and actions already identified and published in the Parish Plan Action Plan. As have our links with neighbouring parishes in resolving issues of common interest. It was particularly helpful in establishing a voluntary "20mph is Plenty" scheme within the parish. It was also crucial in the support and engagement of SDC in the eco-friendly development of the services and facilities of the village hall and playing fields, bringing advice, signposting and resources and through a business-like partnership approach.

What other projects have you got planned for the future?

* To continue the development of a Parish Design Statement in conjunction with SDC to inform Supplementary Planning Guidance

* To produce a Parish Environmental Survey & Plan to identify and raise awareness of sensitive sites and habitats within the parish.

* To continue to review, revise and update the Parish Plan Action Plan annually.
Have the actions from the Plan brought any funding into the community e.g. lottery grants, trusts, Village of the Year etc

Major funding was sought and obtained for both completed phases of the Village Hall redevelopment project from within the parish, local authorities and charitable organisations. The many successful applications were only possible by the project having been identified as a major action in the Parish Plan prior to the creation of the Village Hall Development Plan. In the words of one of the project leaders "the Stroud District Council grant of £35,000 would not have come about without the Parish Plan".

How are you keeping the process alive and advising progress to the community? Supported by a fixed monthly agenda item at Parish Council meetings open to public, the establishment of the four standing committees integrates the outcomes embodied in the Action Plan directly into council business and consequent reporting. Via the Parish website and reports in the Randwick Runner plus celebratory events like open invitations to meetings and official openings. Through annual comprehensive Parish Plan Review meeting

How has this benefited the community? It has focussed greater attention on community cohesion and is successfully addressing the need to improve communication and community involvement in parish that is geographically elongated and comprising several widely dispersed relatively isolated settlements. It has resulted in stronger links with neighbouring parishes and major stakeholders/agencies e.g. SDC, GCC, Police, National Trust and both the local Planning and Highways Departments. It has strengthened the collective sense of purpose and brought common reference points and direction across all areas of parish discussion and development

What lessons have you learned? That consultation is the key to developing and sustaining a Parish Plan together with strong leadership, partnership and work ethic of both the Steering Committee and the Parish Council. To prioritise and pace the implementation of the Action Plan issues with both achievable short term and long term projects in order to maintain impetus, interest energy & sanity!
How does the Action Plan link into the Parish Councils future business planning? It is the main driver and its presence now shapes & guides not only its "day to day" working but also it future direction. However, we are aware that in prioritising & implementing the Action Plan that it is easy for the interests and issues of some sections of the community that are under-represented (e.g. elderly, youth & the very young, etc.) to become marginalised. We are seeking ways to make ensure that their specific interests and issues continue to be championed.

One piece of advice for others? Consult, communicate and involve widely as often as possible throughout all phases of the development and implementation of a Parish Plan and plan for the sustainability of that wider involvement.

Quote on the Parish Plan process: The community itself is the key to a successful Parish Plan. It is a vast reservoir of ideas, talent, and effort, in both its development and implementation. By being actively engaged in the process it enables a more effective and efficient phased delivery of those local issues that itself has identified to improve that particular community's future. A "bottom up" rather than "top down" approach to specific local issues! If the community own the plan they will lead the action!

Ruscombe Brook - update of projects along the brook

This blog entry comes with thanks for info from a variety of sources including Andy Reed of the Land Trust, Ivi Szaboova-Baxendale from SVP and Officers at Stroud District Council. This week I was also able to go and talk to Officers at Cainscross Parish Council and give them an update of work along the brook as well as see the plans for Hamwell Leaze - see below.

1. The Lake at the Lawns - Over £90k bid

Background: During 2006–07, the Stroud Community Land Trust signed a lease with Gloucestershire County Council to take over management of the Lake at the Lawns site, the second site in the Stroud area that it will actively manage. This site, next to Cainscross roundabout, is all that remains of a large country house that used to exist on the site until the 1960s. The lake, small area of woodland, and more formal lawn area is only one of three sites in Cainscross parish that residents have unrestricted access to for walking, picnicking, and generally relaxing and getting closer to wildlife. This gives the site particular importance given that the parish population is over 5,500 people.

British Waterways did carry out some work as part of plans re the canal - see some of the discussion here - the photo above is before the work was undertaken to dredge and improve the site. Considerable work was done although not quite as we had hoped - nevertheless an improvement.

After taking over the lease, Stroud Valleys Project helped the Land Trust to consult with local people about the roles that the site will play in community life, and how the site should be managed. They produced a comprehensive plan which led to a bid being submitted by the Land Trust before Christmas - a major bid for the Big Lottery Changing Spaces programme.

Andy Read, of the Land Trust (and currently Mayor of Stroud) report that they have already been shortlisted from a first stage process. They expect to hear in 10 weeks time. If successful it will be an 18-month project to do most of the repair and enhancement work identified in the management plan for the site. Some of this includes work to reduce the silting: I've requested further details on this as work we will do will hopefully support silt reduction. If not successful in the bid at least they still have everything fully planned and costed and can fundraise on individual items. The total application is just over`£90k - fingers crossed!

2. The Lake at the Lawns - Habitat work

As a result of the Ibstock Cory funding, Stroud Valleys Project were able to maintain and improve biodiversity at this site. This has allowed some on-going improvements to the site. Their work days are great fun and I well remember helping clear Hamwell Leaze and build a 'snake hotel' on one day (see photo) - recent work with volunteers includes:

- built a newt and toad hibernaculum during a habitat creation session for 10 Y9 students from Marling secondary school
- winter bird survey
- organised a training session for volunteers to help with a bat survey
- removed a laurel from the lakeside. This will help improve the water quality by reducing the amount of leaf litter in the water. The laurel will be replaced by a native hedge, which is more suitable for wildlife in terms of cover, nesting opportunities and provision of food.

3. Hamwell Leaze - Plan and Habitat work

Cainscross Parish Council have commissioned a plan to be drawn up for Hamwell Leaze: many months ago I spoke with the project coordinator and am pleased to see that the plan includes a board walk at the willow end. This plan pictured left is different from the 15 year old plan by Water 21 below.

Those visiting the site might have seen some trees marked with white paint. It seems those trees are likely to be removed - understandably those who know the site and have been working on bird and insect surveys are worried that the dead wood will be removed even though it's good habitat for insects. I have telephoned the Parish Clerk and asked that this issue is considered and understand quotes for tree cutting will be considered by the Parish Council next Monday.

There are plans of the project now on the wall at the Cainscross Parish Council building (open I think from 9.30 to 1.00 each day) - you can see them alot more clearly than my poor photo here. I understand these plans have been approved in principle by the Parish.

As a result of the same Ibstock Cory funding noted above the Stroud Valleys Project have been able to maintain and improve biodiversity for wildlife at this site. Recent habitat work at Hamwell Leaze has includes:
- gapped up the hedge and cleared bindweed/grass around the trees
- used the grass to re-stocked the area used for slow-worm hibernation
- cleared bindweed from oak saplings
- cut back overhanging vegetation near footpaths to make walking easier
- fixed chicken wire onto the bridge across the stream to make it safe
- cleared out bird boxes
- planted native bulbs to increase the biodiversity of the site
- organised a birdwatch session to help volunteers recognise garden birds ahead of the RSPB Big Garden Birdwatch
- organised a training session for volunteers to help with a bat survey

4. Acre Place, Puckshole - new culvert and grill details

Photos: Culvert working and below the culvert collapsed

As reported the new culvert and grill are a great improvement over the previous arrangement (see photo and here). In the past heavy rain has led to houses being cut off by a knee deep river and cars being flooded. The new gulley took the place of the previous vertical pipe in the track: this allows flood water (and normal surface water from the track) to drain away following storms. Unfortunately, this may also occasionally act as a “pressure relief valve” if the downstream pipe is surcharged (full capacity exceeded) – just as the vertical pipe did before. For most of the time it should act as a benefit in draining the road.

The final works carried out at Acre Place included the replacement of 2No. vertical screens with a new 45 degree rake-able bar screen and new headwall (est. cost £13k). During the work, it was found that parts of the existing culvert under the track (formed by large stones with a slab stone over approx. size 0.6m x 0.4m) had collapsed, causing obstruction and a reduced capacity. A new twinwall 600mm diameter plastic pipe was therefore laid across the total width of the track so that the other works (screen, headwall) could be completed.

In addition jetting of the culvert downstream through the builder’s yard (made up of old oil cans surrounded in concrete) was also carried out after CCTV work (est. cost £1.5k).

Residents will now monitor the culvert when there is further heavy rain and RBAG will work on phase 2 of plans at the site.

We need a new plan for local traffic calming

Below is my response to news that the local 20 is Plenty signs may have to be taken down. The letter was copied to Parish councillors and the County councillor.

Cartoon: First we have the rubbish incl Highways signage that was left after the snow (see here), now we have news that the 20 is Plenty signage might need to be removed - as Russ in this cartoon suggests Highways would no doubt be delighted if the 20 is Plenty signs disappear.

Letter to John Kay, Stakeholder Manager (Central), Gloucestershire Highways.

I write regarding efforts by myself and both Randwick Parish and Whiteshill and Ruscombe Parish Councils to ensure traffic calming measures are adopted in our area. Indeed many residents have also identified it as a priority for the Councils, as has the newly elected County Councillor for the area.

Four years ago we were told that we were on the verge of getting a mandatory 20 mph across the two wards. I understand we were misinformed at the time, the police then objected at the last minute and plans were shelved. Since then I have had a number of site meetings with and without Highways Officers, as have the Parish Councils. We have sought measures to calm traffic and while Officers have on occasions been helpful we have also been repeatedly frustrated. The latest issue of concern is the call by Highways to remove the '20 is Plenty' signage.

I would welcome a discussion and plan about how to take this issue forward. In particular:

1. A mandatory 20 mph.

The arguments for 20 mph are overwhelming. As you will know when a pedestrian is hit by a car at 40 mph they only have a 15% chance of surviving, at 30mph, 55%, but at 20mph the chance of survival increases to 95%. This is more than sufficient justification for a default 20 mph in residential areas. Amazingly even a 1 mph drop in average speed is estimated to reduce accidents by 6% in urban areas. However research also shows that 20mph limits are a critical success factor in promoting walking, cycling and public transport as alternatives to the private car. This means less CO2 emissions and healthier residents. 20 mph limits help create 'living streets' as this is the speed at which drivers can have eye contact with other users of the street. It is the speed at which pedestrians feel more confident about crossing the road, children play outside their homes and it is quiet enough to hold a conversation.

Both Parish Councils and myself seek a mandatory 20 mph. We are told the Police object to 20 mph in our Parishes. However we read of many other places that are doing it. For example since March 2008 Portsmouth City Council has set all residential roads, bar arterial routes, with a speed limit of 20 mph. No bumps or humps, but most importantly a decision not just made by Traffic Officers but the whole community as they sought a way to deliver lower speeds and a better quality of life for their residents. The argument that police cannot enforce is not, in my view, a sufficient argument to not proceed. A 20 mph is part of how we change the culture.

(i) We would like to work with the Police to overcome their objections. There may for example be traffic calming measures at key sites that will allow the Police to accept our plans for a mandatory 20mph.
(ii) We accept that their are costs attached to Traffic Regulation Orders eg £1,500 plus other charges and staff time. However many in the community feel strongly about this and it maybe possible to find some of this funding.
(iii) We understand that Highways are producing guidance on 20 mph zones and we would very much like to be consulted on this matter - indeed would welcome more information about the plans.
(iv) I note that there is little benefit for a 20 mph zone along the narrower roads: it would need to cover the main roads through Whiteshill and Randwick.

2. 20 is Plenty

Photos: Randwicks' 20 is Plenty signage

Some of us accept that the additional signage (ie the '20 is Plenty' signs) could be distracting to drivers. However we also know that there is strong evidence that such signage slows traffic. Indeed the motivations of accepting County and District advice to go down the '20 is Plenty' route was that it would lead to lower speeds. I for one, was hopeful that this would lead to greater acceptance for a mandatory 20 mph in the area.

I am therefore deeply disappointed by GCC's recent response that the signs must now be temporary. I note that at no time in my discussions nor in any of the emails or paperwork that I have seen, was there a mention of this. I have also tried to look at the Traffic Signs Regulations of 2002 and other regulations and cannot see the part that prevents the signage. I understand that Whiteshill and Ruscombe Parish have also not had any indication that the signs must be temporary. Indeed both Parishes have sought metal signs to be durable and better looking because they understood the signs would be up for a while.

(i) I would be interested to know on what basis GCC are asking for removal? I understand some are not best sited but if this was rectified I would welcome the legal reasons for removing the signs. Indeed I cannot think that removing the signs will play well with most of the community.
(ii) How soon can we put the signs up again?
(iii) Why can other areas have long term '20 is Plenty' zones?
(iv) It would seem important to measure the speeds before signs are taken down to see what effect they have had on speeds. It is clear some vehicles ignore them but I have noticed a change in driving by some cars. Indeed a neighbour says she now never goes faster than 20 mph in the area because the sign reminds her.

3. Other traffic calming measures

Photos: Standish gateways designed to slow traffic as they make drivers think they are going into a different area

Both Parishes have discussed other measures to calm traffic. Whiteshill and Ruscombe Parish have for example had meetings with the public and discussions. Ideas include:
(i) Removal of middle white line in some areas as this is known to slow traffic: this appears to have been done in some places?
(ii) The addition of some form of 'gateway' like at Bibury or Standish to slow traffic entering the village.
(iii) White lines at the edge of roads to give a sense of more narrow roads.
(iv) Possible changes to parking arrangements to help slow traffic on the main road.
(v) Stickers on recycling boxes to say '20 is Plenty' so that once a fortnight drivers get a reminder. This has already been done.
(vi) Measures at the school to slow traffic: road paint was added although this was not welcomed by all as the best way to slow traffic at that site.

I apologise for the length of this letter but wanted to get across some of the issues we have been trying to address. We would welcome thoughts on how best to take this forward? We recognise that the County and yourselves in Highways are particularly stretched in terms of resources, but hope that this will be an opportunity for us all to develop a route map to what is wanted by the local community?

All the best - Philip

Cllr. Philip Booth,
Stroud District councillor for the Randwick, Whiteshill and Ruscombe ward

Conference: Greens support Billy's move to curb bankers bonuses

Motions were passed at conference that mean the Green Party election manifesto will include a top-rate Bankers' Bonuses Tax and a bid to break up big banks. See my main ramble about conference here.

Photo: me at conference

Greens have given support to Billy Bragg's call for bankers' bonuses to be limited to a maximum of £25,000 - but have argued this is only a first step. We would want to propose to the next government that state-owned banks don't pay bonuses at all.

Singer-songwriter Billy Bragg launched an online campaign last month, called NoBonus4RBS.

Caroline Lucas MEP, leader of the Green Party, is quoted saying: "For bankers to continue to expect to be paid bonuses after the crisis of the past 18 months is extraordinary - particularly in banks which are being propped up by the taxpayer. I agree with Billy Bragg: at the very least, and as a first step, I want to see the government limit the bonuses that are paid to employees of any wholly or partly state-owned banks to a maximum of £25,000. I see no reason why any banker should expect a bonus of more than £25,000. Let's remember that we're talking about a bonus on top of their wages, and they're actually very well paid. A bonus of £25,000 is almost the national average wage, and a lot of people work very hard for a whole year to earn £25,000 - or less. So no banker should claim they deserve such a bonus on top of their wages."

Bankers' Bonuses Tax - and a bid to break up the big banks

The proposal is that if a bank, whether state-owned or otherwise, announces it's going to pay £X billion in bonuses, the treasury would take a percentage of £X billion in the form of the Bankers' Bonuses Tax. It would be taken at source, so the bank itself would pay the tax. Of course the recipient of the bonus would then pay tax on the bonus as income as well. And we would be looking to set the rate of the Bankers' Bonus Tax at the top rate.

The Greens are also calling for the break-up of big banks into smaller enterprises "more responsive and accountable to the communities they serve."

See more at Billy's website here.

Homeopathy is under threat

Homeopathy needs our support. If you, like me, have been helped by homeopathy or know someone who has then please take a short moment to support this petition. Parliament is being lobbied today with over 25,000 signatures and I got an email last last night about this online petition that has been restarted.

Number 10 petition:
http://petitions.number10.gov.uk/Homeopathy1/
Sing and pass on and don't forget to verify in the email to make sure it goes through.

Homeopathy worked for me petition:
http://www.hmc21.org/
And follow the 'homeopathy worked for me link'.

The Telegraph are reporting that MPs will be calling for an end to the funding of homeopathy on the NHS as well as suggesting that that claims to ‘treat’ disease should not be used. Understandably there has been much discussion on the web - here is one blog posting some of the evidence in clinical trials showing it works.

Conference: Robin Hood Tax

One of the Emergency Motions that I supported at the Green party conference was backing the "Robin Hood tax" and resolving to include a financial transaction tax in the 2010 manifesto. Strangely by cooincidence have just seen the Kevin Costner Robin Hood film.....see also my main blog about conference here.

Photo: conference cafe area

Anyway this tax is an issue I have already raised on this blog - see here - and indeed I've supported it's predecessor, the Tobin Tax. We have seen hundreds of billions of our money spent on bail-outs, yet the banks are still unreformed, raking in billions in profit and bonuses while the public finances are gutted.

This so-called “Robin Hood tax” on international bank speculation is at last gathering support across the spectrum and could raise hundreds of billions in return for the NHS and schools, as well as helping to tackle poverty and protect the global environment. But it wont be easy....apparently when an online vote on this proposal was launched a Goldman Sachs bank server was used to send in thousands of rigged votes within minutes!

You can sign the petition here:
http://www.avaaz.org/en/robin_hood/?vl

However read first Green economist Molly Scott Cato's view opposing this tax here. That gave me food for thought - I have still signed - the proposal is clearly not the whole answer but a small move that could make a difference - could achieving such a move against the banks spur on the needed reforms?

Conference: motions, quotes and more

Well I've just been helping to put together a press release about Greens going from across the County joining the Green Party Annual Conference in North London last weekend. Some of this blog includes chunks from that draft and more....apols for hurried nature - there are also several other blogs on items from the conference - a couple more tomorrow.

These are exciting times for the Green Party. Whilst there is general distrust and a lack of enthusiasm for the three main parties, there is hope that the first Green MPs will be elected to Westminster in the next election. Caroline Lucas, the party leader and MEP, said Greens are on the verge of an ‘historic breakthrough’ after polls suggested she will beat the ruling Labour Party in Brighton. In her keynote leader's speech she highlighted the key themes for the Greens general election campaign - creating new jobs, protecting the NHS and tackling inequality.

Martin Whiteside, the Green Party Parliamentary candidate for Stroud and a District Councillor (Martin in photo of one of the workshops), who was at the conference, observed that, “Stroud saw Greens polling 20% in elections across the District last year, ahead of Labour and level with the Lib Dems. Electing an MP from one of the big three parties is business as usual. Stroud has a chance to do something different."

One of the speakers at conference noted that Ed Milliband understands climate change but can't act as the measures needed are not - in his parties view - acceptable to the public. A Green vote will let the big parties know otherwise.

Anyway what else? The party fully endorsed the so-called Robin Hood Tax, a tax on international bank speculation that could raise hundreds of billions for the NHS, schools and international development. Greens also argued that by scrapping Trident and expensive Private Finance Initiatives (PFIs) in the NHS, the Green Party could save billions that would be put towards creating jobs where they are needed.

Maximum wage policy

Here's the quote sent in from me to the press - Philip Booth, a Stroud District councillor said of conference: "It is always good to hear about the challenges and successes other Greens are facing. It is an opportunity to learn and be inspired. Never has there been a time when Green politics is needed more - not just for the environment but for economics and for social justice"

Philip Booth added: "The conference looked at many measures to tackle inequality and I was delighted that Greens backed a call for a maximum wage policy that would ensure that the pay of the highest-paid person in an organisation should not exceed the lowest-paid by more than a factor of 10. We also backed a call for marriage equality that would allow same-sex civil marriage and for civil partnerships to be available to all."

Updated health policy

One of the major items at conference was the health voting paper, which entirely updated Green party health policy. This added policies on patient empowerment, calling for a new model of patient-owned co-ops for GP practices, to end NHS subsidies for private healthcare, and breastfeeding. The policy now also includes approval, with appropriate ethical guidelines, for all types of stem call research. It was also generally "slimmed down", removing references to particular treatments and drugs.

Green Party Parliamentary candidate for the Forest, James Greenwood, noted, following the voting on health, that: "Greens are a fresh voice in politics. We want to see an end to private funding in the state-run health service and preventative health policies with screening and a crackdown on processed food loaded with salt, sugar and fat." See more re health policies stuff here.

Conference commercialisation

Photo: Stoned man on roof of conference centre

Well as we see the other parties gear up to their conferences there is a frightening degree of commercialisation which is virtually absent from the Green party conference. The Green party, alone it seems amongst the main parties, still makes policy at conference. At conference Greens debate and decide, whereas Labour now have many committees under its NEC and their conference is now the biggest trade fair in the country.

The Tories are even more centralised with the Lib Dems only being slightly better. Indeed the main party conferences seem to be where party bosses sell their policies to an increasingly sceptical audience and outside the hall there is ever more commercialisation. All this only adds to the lack of faith people have in the political process.

Fairness and inequality

The Green Party has always argued that a fairer distribution of the worlds wealth and resources is the key to reversing climate change and environmental damage to the planet and untold human misery that forces people to leave their homes or descend into warfare over limited resources.

Around the country local councils are poised to make 1000’s of people redundant and cut back on vital services. In contrast, one of the Green party's key pledges for the coming general election will be the creation of a million new jobs. The proposed jobs will be in areas such as public transport, green energy, affordable housing and care for elderly people.

James Greenwood added: "We have been calling for the implementation of our Green New Deal – investment in jobs and our infrastructure to give us long-term sustainable and energy-efficient housing."

See Deputy Leader of the Green party, Adrian Ramsay's comment (see photo of him speaking) on Labour's claims for fairness here - and also see his speech to conference here - it was a cleverly crafted speech that took a look at our public services.

Indeed one of the best sessions at conference was chaired by Caroline Lucas and included speeches by author and professor KatiePickett (photo left - see book "The Spirit Level" which I am now reading) and Johann Hari, the Independent journalist (photo below) - excellent speaker with lots of inspiring stories and a passion about tackling inequality - see his most recent column on why the Tories haven't changed here.

Other quotes from Glos Green folk

Matthew Sidford, from Gloucester Green party said: "People thirst for change, yet there's little real change on offer from the other parties. Does anyone believe that Brown has earned another five years in power? Or that Britain will be a fairer and more just place to live if David Cameron becomes Prime Minister?"

Miriam Yagud, a Dursley Town Councillor, said: "All over the country, Green councillors are already making a real difference. Low pay is a real issue in our area. In Lewisham and Norwich, Green Councillors have successfully raised the wages of the lowest paid workers well above the minimum wage. We are protecting jobs and services, and working with people to find creative solutions to local problems.” See more re LOw wage stuff here.

Among the motions passed at conference were:

* Supporting the British Medical Association campaign against privatisation in the NHS.
* Supporting Billy Bragg's campaign against bankers' bonuses.
* On Turkish democracy and Kurdish rights.
* Expressing concern about increasing EU targets on biofuel targets.
* Backing the "Robin Hood tax" and resolving to include a financial transaction tax in the 2010 manifesto
* Backing a post-general election Campaign Against Climate Change event to call on the new government to make climate change its No 1 priority.
* Calling for a campaign against inappropriate funding of political parties.
* Expressing solidarity with the Yarl's Wood protests and calling for the "Yarl's Wood Four" to be released.

Conference: Caroline Lucas speech

Well I had meant to add bits and pieces regarding the Green party conference in North London at the weekend but have been too busy - I will do it very soon!! This week and last we seem to have had many Green party meetings - election time is drawing near and we are busy putting together leaflets and organsing the campaigns.....

Photo: me at conference

Anyhow the conference venue was not perfect - The Arts Depot in North Finchley - a nice enough modern building but for the main sessions we sat in rows rather than more casually as we usual do at tables....and no trees or greenery anywhere....

But enough of the building I wanted to share Caroline Lucas' opening speech for the conference. See it here in full: it is worth a look. More on conference soon but must get to afternoon and evening meeting now at Ebley Mill.

Incinerators: Paul Connett's presentation

If you missed Prof. Paul Connett's Presentation on 4th Feb at King's Stanley, you might like to view the Power Point Slides (in two parts). These slides are now available at: www.glosain.org.uk

They hope to also have a film recording of a similar presentation available soon. See my previous blog on the evening here.

Cartoon: by Russ for this blog - let's hope they do come to senses!

Food Inc comes to Minch

I'm back from the Green party conference in London - more of that soon but a busy few days ahead - just wanted to get this notice out - the film Food Inc will play at the Market House in Minch on 16th March at 7.30pm. Booking is recommended- tickets from Quadra or M&B stores at £5 (£4) or email transitionminch (at) btinternet.com.

I just got an email from the folks at Transition Minch who saw the film in Bath and are organising the event - they said it is well worth a viewing....

Michael Sheldon, of Transition Minch writes: "For anyone who eats food, seeing this film is a must"! It was the biggest selling dvd in the US last year and we feel everyone should realise how food is being produced. If you want more information go to the FOOD, INC. website: www.foodincmovie.co.uk "

It is Oscar Nominated for Best Documentary 2010. It is great that Transition Minch are giving folk locally a chance to see it. Here's more from the advertising re the film: "Lifting the veil on the powerful interests at the heart of US agriculture, FOOD, INC. gives a revelatory insight into a world that big business would rather we didn't see. Shot through with black humour and smart visual effects, the film is as entertaining as it is informative, following the journey of our food from seed to supermarket. This is a process defined by industrial systemisation, economic exploitation and political collusion. The new mantra is 'fatter, bigger, cheaper', as a cabal of major corporations present the illusion of choice while squeezing the life out of the competition, the countryside and, ultimately, the planet."

Field Bar wines of Randwick

I read in Stroud Life this week about a couple in Randwick, Alice Barfield (hence the name of the wines) and Matt Eaton, who have made a business by turning their cottage in Church Road into a winery. As regular blog readers will know, every now and then, I cover local businesses in Randwick, Whiteshill and Ruscombe....well not sure how I missed this one.....

As their website says: "Field Bar Wine produce and sell a range of wines made from delicious, locally picked and grown fruits. We have developed a range of wines made from all manner of fruit and flowers like Strawberry and Elderflower. Our range is constantly expanding and evolving...Where possible, we source our produce from local hedgerow and suppliers, and make all the wine by hand in our micro-winery in the Cotswolds. We don't add extra flavourings or additives to our wines to keep them as pure and fresh as possible."

In Stroud Life Alice is quoted saying: "We are gambling everything in the middle of a recession. But it is something we simply love doing.....They are dry wines. They are not sweet, in fact they're quite tart and good with food."

Now that gets me interested - there is a time and place for those sweet fruit wines - and in my view there are not so many times or places! But when you talk dry, that sounds intriguing and I'll be supporting them next time I get to see them at the Farmers Market. A very good luck to Field Bar wines indeed.

The wines are available at Stroud Farmers Market on 2nd and 4th Saturdays - See more at: www.fieldbarwine.co.uk

Petition: it is a bad time for public spending cuts

Today over 60 leading economists have written to the Financial Times, to tell the Chancellor and the Shadow Chancellor it's a bad time to cut public spending [see here]. They say that it's too soon to know that the UK economy is recovering and that cuts too early could send us into a disastrous 'double-dip' recession.

Photo: snow again but strangely heavy in places like Dursley and Stonehouse but none in Stroud - anyhow this great pic of Whiteshill Church was from Chris Tracey, a Ruscombe resident - taken in the previous snow falls.

The campaign 38 degrees has launched an online petition - it takes less than a minute to sign at: www.38degrees.org.uk/dont-risk-the-recovery/

This is more of what they write: "This recession has hit the UK hard. Millions of us have suffered unemployment or the stress of feeling our jobs and homes under threat. There are some signs the worst may be over, but there's a danger that recovery may be threatened by politicians competing to look tough on cuts. The economy will be a key issue at the general election. But if politicians and the media get obsessed with a race to cut spending, protecting jobs and homes could be neglected. We need to prove that the public want politicians who put jobs and stability first. A massive petition against cuts will capture the media's attention, and persuade journalists to challenge politicians to show us their plans to reduce unemployment and poverty, not just their plans to cut spending."

The comment I left on the email I sent to the Chancellor and Shadow Chancellor relates to the need for a Green New Deal - see more here about what is really possible - at that website there are real costed proposals that will mean more jobs and a real investment in the future.

Woodies: I'm moving up!

For the past couple of years I've been a leader helping to run the Willow Elfin Woodcraft Folk group for 6 to 9 year olds. Well now my partner's grandchild is moving up into pioneers so I will be going to. It will be v sad to say good bye to the children - and indeed parents - our group has been a wonderfully friendly and supportive group with loads of interesting stuff that we have got up to...

Photo: Rollerskating: I sadly couldn't join in due to a twisted ankle.

Last week we had the moving up ceremony at Stratford Park - an excuse for all the Woodies groups to meet and go roller-skating - but also say goodbye to those they leave behind. One of my last duties as a leader was to complete a short report of our activities in the last year. I enclose it below for those interested in joining Woodies - also follow the label below to a number of previous blogs and stuff about history etc.

The group started the year with only a handful of members due partly to a number of Elfins moving up. However the group quickly regained it's strength with close to 20 members for most of the year. A number of parents have taken on the leaders role so we have seen a wide-range of activities each week during school term-time. These have included leading the carnival procession with lanterns at the Stroud Goodwill evening at Christmas, being guests twice on Stroud FM to talk about Woodies, a trip to the Gloucester climbing centre, making a hugely colourful banner, making rafts and trying to float them down the Chalford brook, making bows and arrows and trying them out, many music and singing sessions, various craft activities, nature walks and den-making activities and more.

Willow Elfin's also helped initiate and participate in two events to support the 350.org climate change day: planting 350 trees locally with other Woodcraft Folk groups and helping make some of the 350 beehouses for solitary bees. Some of the Willow Elfins have also joined other Woodies for the annual Stroud Camp, the Sausage Sizzle on the common, roller skating at Stratford park and the Levellers Day procession at Burford. We would very much like to thank the Coop for it's support, which particularly allows some of our low income members to participate fully in our activities.

Incineration is wrong

Nicola Hillary, a Green party member, had her letter published in the local papers this week about the Paul Connett talk and incineration. It was not specifically a local Green party policy letter (see that here), but more a personal view - it raised some interesting discussions....letter first....but also see link at bottom re email campaign against incineration.....

Cartoon: By Russ

I went along to the presentation on waste and incineration at King Stanley Village Hall on 4th February with with the view that incineration was not such a bad thing, but I have now been completed convinced that Gloucestershire County Council is about to take a disastrous decision by building an incinerator for our waste.

The speaker, Dr Paul Connett, is a Professor of Chemistry from New York, an international waste expert with years of experience, who had recently been called to advise the UN on incineration. He was an amazing speaker, very passionate and entertaining.

The big problems with incineration of our waste is the dioxins and nanoparticles of toxic heavy metals which is produced in the burning, and there is no technology - and no prospect of any technology - which can remove them from the output of an incinerator. These dioxins are hormone-mimickers which can cause all sorts of trouble when they get in our bodies. Apart from anything else they get concentrated by a huge amount when eaten by cows - and thus get into the milk - and there are loads of dairy farms near Javelin Park. Also, they are particularly harmful to babies in the womb, and as the mother of two small children, that is enough to convince me.

What about the electricity that could be produced? Well apparently incineration is an incredibly expensive way to produce electricity, we would be better spending our money on other renewable energy schemes.

Dr Connett described many communities in Europe and North America who he had been involved with, who had achieved 70-80% recycling of waste, through nothing more technological than weekly door-step collections of recycling, rubbish and food waste, combined with dedicated repair and recycling centres at household waste sites, which saved from landfill so much of the stuff that could be repaired, stripped down or of use to somebody. Obviously this costs money - the food waste collections in the Stanleys were stopped because of the cost - but will it really cost more than the millions of an incinerator?

Also, the clincher is that incineration of 4 tonnes of rubbish leaves 1 tonne of highly toxic ash, which needs to be landfilled. So we can do just as well if we achieve 70-80% recycling. But the toxic ash is so toxic that other countries such as Japan, Germany and Austria treat it as they do their nuclear waste - vitrifying it into glass or burying it in protective containers in salt mines.

It would seem preferable to aim to recycle 80% of our rubbish leaving just 20% that it is not possible to recycle but that is at least not highly toxic. Lets take on the 80% challenge.

Council chiefs need to rule out the possibility of an incinerator to deal with the county’s waste.

Yours sincerely, Nicola Hillary

Well for some, the dioxins are the least important aspect - an issue I've talked about before - indeed some campaigners against incineration question whether they are any worse than particulates from traffic and other sources - however I do think there is an issue re nanoparticles and I have no problem with adding this objection to the many other reasons why we should not have an incinerator.

The crucial issue re incineration must surely be that it is a colossal waste of resources. Our waste is going to become an increasingly important source of raw materials. Furthermore a large incinerator has a huge potential to be a white elephant that ties us into a 24 year plus contract. This would exclude rapidly developing technologies and could even leave us open to paying compensation to contractors if we don't produce enough waste.

And yes we are right to call for 80% recycled (and indeed more - FoE estimate 93% of domestic waste is recyclable in the longer term) - it is shocking the County are talking about a miserable 60% - however the question is about the residual waste - ie the remaining 20% (if we go for 80% in the next few years) - that 20% is want the county wants the incinerator for - we need solutions for the remaining waste - and indeed there are alternatives to incineration like MBT with AD that are much better.

See FoE email campaign here against incineration and my report re the Paul Connett evening here.