31 Jan 2010

Make Your Own David Cameron Poster!

I came across this website - Make Your Own David Cameron poster - and it had some amusing posters with great catch lines - see some of them at: www.mydavidcameron.com/

My poster version doesn't really do justice....but do have to note very real concerns if Tories get in - not listing the environment as a priority is unforgiveable (see The Independent article here) and it seems clear they plan serious cuts to services and make tax cuts for the wealthy.

Two locals:new restaurant and film-maker

This blog occasionally covers news of local folk from Whiteshill, Ruscombe or Randwick...here in this post are two that have already had a mention in the local press.

Neil Leighton-Boyce

Stroud has lost the Greyhound and Market Tavern pubs so it is great to see trained chef Neil Boyce, 22, who is from Whiteshill, opening 'Utopia' - Stroud’s newest restaurant. The eatery will largely serve organic dishes made with locally sourced produce wherever possible - like Day's Cottage juices and Stroud Brewery beers.

The fully licensed bistro has beautiful ash flooring from Westonbirt Arboretum, a range of Fairtrade teas and coffees and free in-house WiFi Internet access for customers. It also has its entire power supply sourced from 100 per cent renewable energy firm Good Energy. Good on them indeed.

I'm planning a visit as soon as I can find an excuse and an evening - Utopia's Facebook site already has 385 fans - Visit Utopia at 50 High Street, Stroud, GL5 1AN or call 01453 756 043 to book a table.

Guy Davies

Meanwhile congrats to Guy Davies, 18, from Randwick who has just been awarded a scholarship to study at the famous New York Film Academy (NYFA). Educated at Wycliffe College Guy was accepted for the one-year course which started at the beginning of the month - the Brett Rattner scholarship offers up to $15,000 - some folk might have seen him act in the Jenny Wren productions locally - he played Laurie Lee in their 'Cider with Rosie'. I'm sure will be hearing more of him soon.

30 Jan 2010

Budget at Full Council on 21st Jan

As usual a busy week and have a cold so not firing on all cylinders but here's a quick round-up of the Full Council meeting last week and a couple of other recent meetings....

Photos: wow what a frost today

These are challenging times and there is no doubt the administration had some very hard decisions to make the budget balance - even now there are serious risks attached to it like will the canal really come in on budget? Will we get the Icelandic bank money back? What will a new Government mean for local Councils? How will the recession continue to impact...Francis Roden, Leader of SDC gave a speech - see it here on SNJ website - as an indication of how the recession is biting, the Council's revenue and benefits service paid benefits totaling £32.5 million this year compared to £26 million the previous year - an increase of 25%!

So where will cuts fall? Well already huge cuts have been made by senior staff leaving and not being replaced - this has already had a noticeable impact on other senior staff left behind - already busy workloads have massively increased - there have been other cuts too when other staff have left and the posts not refilled - again putting pressure on remaining staff....

Other cuts have come to community grants and rises in car parking charges are now agreed. All this led to Stroud District Council approving a 1.9 per cent increase in its portion of the council tax.

Greens and others opposed the Tories plans - here's a quote in the SNJ summing it up: "Some councillors at the budget meeting said the authority should investigate borrowing cash to improve services during this period of low interest rates. Cllr Sarah Lunnon (Green) said: 'What we actually need at this moment is to take a brave decision like we did on the canal and borrow some money so we can fund some of our initiatives.'"

For me it is crucial that we look at borrowing - and I was delighted that the tories did not rule it out for the future. It makes sense - especially if we can spend now to make significant energy efficincy savings and install renewables - indeed we have the potential to develop an income stream in the future - especially when most renewables will have paybacks withing 7 to 10 years - and with rising energy prices even more!!

Arts funding U-turn

The good news is that SDC has made an 11th hour U-turn on proposals to slash grants to two arts organisations in the area. Both Prema Arts Centre, in Uley, which receives £10,000 in funding from the district council, and Stroud Valleys Artspace, which receives £12,000, will now get their full grants after fears were raised that the Arts Council would withdraw their funding if the council decided to cut its grants to the organisations. However it does not look like Stroud Valleys Project will have it's grant reduction reinstalled.

Joint-Use leisure centres

I have reported on this before - see here - well at Full Council this issue was not up for discussion as it was for a special meeting of Cabinet this last Thursday. Well sadly the future of Nailsworth Recreation Centre now hangs in the balance after Cabinet voted to go forward with plans to stop funding the facility. As they noted this is only a 'notice of intent' to terminate the informal agreements to run Nailsworth Recreation Centre, Vale of Berkeley Sports Centre and Wotton Pool - but let's get real - in practice their decision will mean vital funding is cut from the facilities. Here's how the SNJ report:

Cllr Keith Pearson, cabinet member for regeneration, said: "We are only talking about handing back control of the facilities, we have never used the word closed."

Cllr Fi Macmillan (Green, Nailsworth) told the meeting that governors at Nailsworth Primary School said the centre would close if management was handed back as the school did not have the money to fund it.

The recommendations must be approved by full council on Thursday 25th February but it is not looking so good.

Members Development Group

This is a group that usually only meets a handful of times each year but we've had a number of additional meetings recently - don't think I've even mentioned I sit on this group - anyhow one of the areas we've been looking at his IT equipment used by councillors. It has traditionally been the case that Councils provide laptops for members.

SDC are now looking at giving a grant in the first year of £300 per councillor to purshase their own laptop and printer if necessary - this would mean significant savings but one issue I've ensured is addressed is that the principle is maintained that no councillor should be disatvantaged or not be able to function through lack of money....if a computer breaks before the guarantee runs out it is right that consideration is given to a replacement.

Some councillors have no problems re money but some are on low income and if we are to make the Council body representative then we need to ensure that councillors are not excluded through lack of money.

I've run out of puff writing - three other scrutiny meetings this last week but will write of those when their reports are presented in February.

28 Jan 2010

After the snow: why the mess?

I have discussed some of the aftermath of the sledging and snow - see here. We are now looking at what can be done longer term - the notices put up did help reduce the mess but what else? The letter below sent to the SNJ is from a local farmer and with the photo gives some indication of some of the mess left....

Interestingly the District Council also report more litter on the roads during the snow - perhaps more people out walking?

Madam - Cans Sweet papers Crisp packets Bottles Bin liners Broken sledges Assorted hardboard Piles of plastic sheeting A car bonnet Part of a canoe Car tyres Several stolen road signs And A thermos flask and bunch of keys

These are some of the items which had to be cleared after 8 days of tobogganing on fields in Randwick, Ruscombe, Whiteshill, Cainscross and Stonehouse - all land in the Cotswolds AONB and along the Cotswold Way, and part of my farm. This depressing picture was duplicated around the 5 Valleys, on Common land and other farms, where easy access to hills is possible. This has been anti-social behaviour on a large scale, and in some instances included wanton damage to property such as fences, gates and water courses. As such, it raises a number of questions.

Since this also happened in February last year, why did it not in 1981? Where were the parents in this, in informing and controlling their children? The schools – what are they teaching about the countryside and wider social issues of responsibility and care? Why is it deemed safe for children to career down hills (and sometimes along streets) on toboggans, yet trying to get them onto farms to learn more about the countryside, food production and the environment is pretty well impossible, sometimes on the grounds of so called risk. (I spent 3 years attempting to develop links with 10 local schools to use my farm as a learning classroom, only for this to founder for lack of take up).

The only offers of help to clear up over the 40 acres concerned, came from non-tobogganing local people or Parish/Town Councillors and local environmental groups? Why, and where were the families who created this mess when it had to be man/woman handled across sodden fields, bagged up and left by the road side? And finally, why does the press portray all this sledging as so fantastic? Can anybody answer these questions for me please?

Julia Currie - Ebley

27 Jan 2010

Where will all the houses go?

Well to cut a very long story short on the basis of current figures about what is planned for Stroud District and what was in the Regional Spatial Strategy we have some 1,500 to 2,000 homes to build each year.

Photo: Ruscombe fields that were wanted for development.

Well Stroud District Council is following the legal stuff to develop it's Core Strategy about how those homes will be allocated. Yesterday evening was a Policy Seminar to hear about the next stages and the proposed 7 Alternative Strategies for dealing with development in the District up to 2026 and the proposed policies to guide that development.

The Council is drafting it's new planning framework for the District known as the Local Development Framework (LDF). This will eventually supersede the current Local Plan – but unlike the Local Plan, the Local Development Framework is made up of a portfolio of separate planning policy documents, which will address different policy topics in the future. Hope I haven't lost you yet....

At the centre of the LDF is the Core Strategy. This document will provide an overview of the District and set principles and policies to guide development up to 2026. The Core Strategy will form the basis of planning policy decisions for the District, and it will set the context for other more detailed planning policy documents in the future.

In March/April 2009 the Council consulted on the key Issues that the Core Strategy should consider. Since then the findings of that consultation have been combined with leading issues raised by national and regional planning guidance in order to prepare a number of background papers to support the next stage of production and consultation – the Alternative Strategies.

The Council will soon be consulting the public again on this next stage – seeking views on 7 alternative ways of seeing development distributed in the District and on proposed policies to guide development. The consultation period will run from 8 February to 22 March 2010 when we will again speak with Parish and Town Councils.

Well I've had the first glimpse of the proposed 7 strategies and immediately have concerns about their implications - not just for our area but the whole District. I have not seen the full details but know we need to get this right - some of the proposals mean more houses to be squeezed in to the villages and possibly significantly more homes - but this is not the time to panic - there is much more to the strategies including employment sites and more so I would urge folk to consider them when the consultation is launched.

Strategic Housing Land Availability Assessment

Meanwhile the Strategic Housing Land Availability Assessment (SHLAA) has now been completed - see my blog here with details of potential impact locally.

The SHLAA seeks to identify and assess all potential sources of housing supply to meet the Districts needs to 2026. The final report is available to view online here.

There is also a page of site assessments - you can see the numbers on this map and download the appropriate report.

It is important to note that the SHLAA does not allocate housing sites. The decisions on which of these sites may be allocated will take place through the development of the Core Strategy. Any planning applications relating to any of these sites that pre-empt that process will still need to be considered through the Council’s development control system.

Whilst there is no specific requirement to consult on the results of the SHLAA, the selection of potential housing allocations is part of the Core Strategy preparation process and will be subject to public consultation. It is in my view an important consideration to consider these sites when making a response to the Core Strategy.

I would welcome feedback on any of this once the consultation gets going. Is it time to reform the Ruscombe Valley Action Group?

26 Jan 2010

More on the Village Hall loo opening!!

You will see my previous blog with photos of the opening here - this blog post has more from the 'official photographers' plus the official press release from Alan Tomlinson and his great toilet-opening speech!

Over seventy villagers anxiously waited cross legged outside the village hall to witness the official opening ceremony of the new toilet block last Saturday.

First the press release for the Randwick Runner:

Over the last 16 months over £22,000 has been raised for the ambitious project -c omprising a children’s toilet, disabled access toilet and referee’s changing room with shower. In his opening speech Mayor Tomlinson paid tribute to the on going enthusiasm for the hall from the village, acknowledging over £6,000 had been donated from with in the community. Also acknowledged were donations from charities outside of the village who share our community values. Theses include the Summerfield Trust, the Bernard Stanley Foundation, the Garfield Weston Foundation, Stroud Lions Club, the Langtree Trust, Barnwood House and most notably Gloucestershire Environmental Trust on behalf of Cory Environmental using landfill tax credits who contributed an extremely generous £8,000. Randwick Parish Council also continue to donate £3,000 per year to the hall.

Val and Harden Flack were given a special mention for their tireless work. Mayor Tomo said: "Despite all good intentions no project goes anywhere without the shakers and movers. We are particularly blessed on the village hall committee to have Team Flack. Harden is always here giving his support, on call at a moments notice if we need him to meet contractors, help sort out problems, for advice and general support. And behind every great man there is a great woman. This is absolutely true. Val put her hand up for this project, has raised all the money from outside bodies as well as managing the project. She has been the driving force and I can tell you this has been no mean feat."

Val was then presented with a crystal rose bowl engraved “Presented to Val Flack for an outstanding contribution to the village of Randwick 2009”

Tony Williams was then asked to cut the ribbon. He amused the crowd with his comment: “Not only can I now use the loo at the hall but I can have a shower at the same time”.

Tony, followed by other wheelchair bound villagers, Vic Watkins and Aunty Margaret then led the onlookers into the hall where Brain Farrer had displayed some photos of the old toilets – as if anyone could forget them! Ladies of the village Jane Cant, Sue Tomlinson and Joy Kennard had prepared some delicious cakes for everyone to share and quite few offered to help in the kitchen making tea. Everyone had a wonderful time and £62 was collected towards the Haiti Earthquake appeal. Well done Randwick you have excelled yourselves yet again!

Alan Tomlinson's loo-opening speech

Open day speech 11am Sat 23rd January 2010

It seems like no time since we all stood here and Val asked for a few pennies towards the next phase of the village hall development plan - a new toilet block complete with a childrens toilet, disabled access toilet and ref s changing room with shower . In fact that was just 16 months ago. What an amazing achievement to raise enough money in just 9 months and then go on to deliver a workable scheme in the following 7 months.

What has been particularly inspiring, although perhaps not surprising knowing this village and its community, is the amount of local support. Every single village organisation has made a contribution in some way.

Looking back through the records the enthusiasm for the hall is as strong today as it has been throughout its entire history. Back in 1946 it took 3 years to raise the equivalent of £18K to purchase the playing field. Between 1957 and 1962 todays equivalent of £30K was raised for the current building.

And today it seems not a week goes by without a contribution being given by an individual. Only last week we received £235 from one villager's birthday collection. It is pleasing to know how strongly this resource is valued in the village and this is the inspiration to keep developing it for such a deserving and appreciative bunch of people. The community alone has donated over £6000 in the past 16 months -all this without any prompting -and money is still coming in!

In addition to local contributions we have received donations from a number of organisations outside the village who share our community values. These include

summerfield trust
Bernard Stanley foundaion
garfield weston foundation
lions club
langtree trust
barnwood house

And most notably
GET on behalf of Cory environmental who alone donated £8000 using landfill tax credits

Also we need to thank RPC for their on going commitment to the village, contributing £3000 per year for development of the hall.

But it takes more than money to make things happen. Thanks go to Roger Dean builders and in particular Gary Taylor who did a lot of the work, patiently working with organisations such as Playgroup to minimise any disruption. I know it was testing for all at times but worth it I'm sure you will agree.

Despite all good intentions no project goes anywhere without the shakers and movers. We are particularly blessed on the VH Co to have Team Flack. Harden is always here giving his support, on call at a moments notice if we need him to meet contractors, help sort out problems, for advice and general support.

Behind every great man there is a great woman. And this is absolutely true. Val put her hand up for this project, has raised all the money from outside bodies as well as managing the project. She has been the driving force and I can tell you this has been no mean feat.

In recognition of Val's efforts we have a little presentation for her. So if you would like to step forward Val, I am sure you have a few words to say........

PRESENTATION

And now I would like to ask Tony Williams to officially open our new toilet block.

CUT RIBBON

25 Jan 2010

Potato Day for Stroud?

Saturday saw me setting off, after the opening of the Village Hall loo, for Potato Day in Malmesbury Town Hall. We apparently consume an average of 500 potatoes each year but most of us end up with just a handful of varieties grown for the supermarkets. Well in Malmesbury they had some 55 varieties for sale and more to look at including one, the Mairsland Queen, at £25 each tuber (see below)!

Photos: Malmesbury Potato Day

Potatoes are the world's fourth largest food crop following rice, wheat and maize. Peru is the birth place of the tatty but 99% of tatties trace their heritage back to Chile. They came to Europe in 1536 - then in 1846 blight hit - and the horrors of the Great Irish Famine. Apparently there are some 4,000 varieties (see here). See more about the potato at Wikipedia here.

I loved learning more about potatoes at the event - talking to the handful of experts and others browsing the rows of buckets there - Dave of Green Seeds who organised the event, recommended various potatoes - Lady Cristal and Kestral were a couple I picked - and I learnt that early varieties tend to crop before blight comes along while varieties such as Verity and Sante are resistant to blight.

Dave Chappell, a potato expert from Wales, dubbed 'Taffy Tattie' (see below) was also there with a collection of tubers that he had grown and offers to do talks locally if folk wanted. He had some wonderful old photos of himself with all the gardening greats from Percy Thrower to Geoff Hamilton.

There was also a cafe with cakes and more.

Other Potato Days

Garden Organic's National Potato Day is Sunday 31st January this year - see more here including a video celebrating the potato and looking at potato day at Ryton Organic Gardens in 2008. It started 17 years ago in 1994 however Hampshire is perhaps best known for Potato Day and their 12th Potato Day with over 150 varieties is all of next weekend: www.potatoday.org/

Other Potato Day's can be found at: www.potatoday.org/potatodays.htm. Dundry Nurseries are the only place in Gloucestershire that do a Potato weekend - near Cheltenham and Junction 11 on M5 - but that was also this weekend so you've missed it this year!

The Potato Council even produce packs for schools to get involved with recipes - see here. They also have recipes on their site at: www.lovepotatoes.co.uk/

Stroud Potato Day

My thoughts are that it is time we did something here in Stroud to celebrate the great diversity of tatties and encourage more of us to grow them. We already have Apple Day celebrated locally (See display left at Farmers Market last year) - indeed we've also been out juicing in a local orchard - see here.

Anyhow I have already started to make contacts with the Farmers Market to see what sort of event could be planned. Green seeds would be very happy to bring their display. Any thoughts, ideas and help would be greatly received!!

Grow more potatoes

What’s good about the tatty is that they can be grown in all sorts of spaces - allotment plot, veg patch or simple patio pot. They seem a great way to help folk grow more of their own veg?

Anyway I came across this site here which has several pages on how to grow potatoes. I am looking forward to growing my collection of varieties....

24 Jan 2010

Ceilidh on 30th Jan at Randwick for Haiti

Last week was bloggers day for Haiti (another on 1st Feb) - and locally already folk are already raising money - the opening of the loos on Saturday at Randwick Village Hall added £62 to the Haiti fund - and in Whiteshill too money has been raised.

Photo: frosty morning across Ruscombe fields

Now comes a Ceilidh on Saturday, 30th January at Randwick Village Hall to raise funds for the disaster appeal. The band will be the 'usual suspects' under the name of "The Randwick Disaster Band" and various callers will be on hand.

There is no entry price but they are asking for donations on the door - plus anything else you would like to give during the evening. The traditional re-cycling raffle will be held - all prizes to be unwanted prizes from previous raffles (donations please!). Light refreshments (for a donation) and tap water (free) will be available - otherwise bring your own.

The advert says: "Please support us by coming to dance, join the band, call some dances, or just for the good company and music. It would be nice to have an interval dance display so if you are part of a Morris, Rapper, Appalachian, Sword or any other traditional dance club, please come forward and show off for a good cause - advance knowledge would be useful. Thanks to the generosity if the Randwick Village Hall Committee in waiving the fees, ALL the proceeds will go to the disaster appeal. If you live too far from Randwick to come - organise your own!"

Details: Starts at 7:30 pm. Band - Anyone who turns up with an instrument. Callers - Richard Hannah plus any one else who wants to have a go. All receipts will be passed to the Disaster Emergency Committee (www.DEC.ORG.UK). If you want to support this but cannot come, please visit their web site or send a cheque made payable to "DEC HAITI EARTHQUAKE" and it will be included with the evenings donation. To find Randwick Village Hall use http://www.multimap.com/s/TwoRJwMz (Post code GL6 6JA). Contact for tickets: Richard Hannah - 01905 371 268 and Norma Mills - 01453 885 543

Snow all gone

Well the snow has gone and huge thanks must go to all who helped folk manage through the difficult times. I have to say it was a little shocking to have more snow on Wednesday - it took me an hour and three quarters to get to Gloucester in the car for work and some very dicey moments from other car drivers.....

Photos: Pics mostly from last Wednesday which includes below a grit lorry that got stuck on the corner near More Hall Convent - of course they had plenty of grit to rescuie themselves

We are of course now left with what the county Council estimate could be a £5 million bill for filling potholes! With finances already in a difficult position this potentially could have a very serious impact.

I have heard many stories of neighbours being wonderful - particular thanks for example must go to Cainscross Parish Councillor Christopher Capener who helped a local Randwick farm owner clear some of the rubbish left after the sledgers had gone. This included road signs (including some from Slad Road!), a car bonnet and much more.

However none of this was a touch on last year when vast amounts were cleared away by a team of litter pickers - this year it seems talking to sledgers and the notices put up - see here - did help.

We are now looking at ways to improve that signage if more snow comes - one suggestion - possibly tongue in cheek was an adopt a stile scheme where folk put up the notices on their local stile? Any other suggestions welcomed!

Grit

Anyhow we also had some nickers-of-grit - see here. This led to press announcements and notices going up but I am not sure this helped at one grit bin in Whiteshill.

Of course the biggest grit-nickers were the Government - we were told in the midst of all the snow that only major roads in Gloucestershire will be gritted after the council had to ration salt after the government took control of supplies.

The government said it would control all salt deliveries due to the national shortage. Of course this is right to direct where most needed but seems a little unfair when Glos had got good stocks due to the mess last February when they had to buy table salt.

Indeed salt stocks had been increased by 53 per cent to the maximum capacity of 7,500 tonnes and more was to be re-ordered from supplier Salt Union throughout the winter to ensure this was maintained. Anyhow I have been generally impressed with the vast gritting and ploughing tasks carried out - but of course here in this ward we have suffered quite badly from lack of gritted roads - at times they have been very dangerous and several days there was no access other than by 4x4 - indeed more gritted teeth than gritted roads?!

Pavements

One area we need to get better at is the pavements - these seem to be left until last and leave pedestrians to walk in the road. In a survey by the Local Government Association nearly three quarters of people would back a law to protect householders who cleared snow away from a pavement outside their home from being sued by people who injured themselves slipping on it. A further 59% said they would support a legal obligation on householders - like in several other countries - to make sure the pavement outside their homes was clear of snow. This seems less possible as I can't see some vulnerable or disabled householders doing that - or those away on holiday etc - but would be interested to learn more??

Certainly one solicitor on the radio said he could not see someone suing and winning in the courts for clearing snow...

In terms of the grit bins (see many previous posts on this like here) we have had some success recently in re-siting some bins locally although there are still some problems and we have also not yet got an alternative to grit that can be used (see letter last year on this here). Whiteshill and Ruscombe Parish have also purshased some better bins which are much neater, safer and don't leak salt like the older broken plastic bins.

Other Ruscombe Green recent snow Blogs

One of my most popular blogs about the snow was how to make a snow lantern - see here - and the pics of the Redwing - indeed I had several emails from others locally who have also spotted this wee bird - and one from a keen birder who said even though the snow has gone please keep feeding the birds! See here deer in snow and here woods. Lastly a link here to the post "Weather is not climate".

To finish do please keep sending emails if you have thoughts on the recent weather and how we can better prepare for another such event....

23 Jan 2010

Crowd of 80 see Randwick Village Hall loos open

Today saw a crowd of nearly 80 people come to the opening of our village hall's loos. I have to note it has been an impressive feat - what other village would have 80 folk come out to open loos? And what other village could raise the funds in some 7 months?

Photos: Alan Tomlinson getting ribbon ready for opening, Val Flack, two photos of crowd, the new plaque with improvements listed, the childrens toilet (hugely popular with little ones) and the shower/disabled loo.

Huge congrats must go to all who helped make it possible - but as Alan Tomlinson, Randwick Wap Mayor said in the opening speech, particular thanks to 'Team Flack' - Hardon and especially Val Flack for their huge efforts to make it possible.

It was a lovely morning with a great selection of cakes all in aid of Haiti. Indeed there is also a Ceilidh being organised on Saturday, 30th January at the Randwick Village Hall to raise funds for the disaster appeal. More of that in another blog coming soon but more info from Richard Hannah on 01905 371 268.

All this reminds me of 15 months ago when we opened the toilets at the Whiteshill and Ruscombe Village Shop - see here. Then they used toilet roll instead of ribbon but clearly Randwick are a little more upmarket?! But nice to see that the ribbon was recycled from a wedding at the church!
Anyway I left the Village Hall to go to a Potato Day - more of that in a blog on Monday. Meanwhile see here how to book the Village hall.

22 Jan 2010

Call for moratorium on major road building

This week I read a report (see here) showing how road building is a huge gamble and poor value for money. This is not a surprise as it is an issue I have raised before (see for example here).

Image: from Green party election material

As the Campaign for Better Transport note: "It's not right to spend around £1 billion a year on road schemes if the Government can’t predict what the impacts will be...The Highways Agency has known about these forecasting problems for a while. Earlier this year it released a report by engineering consultants Atkins which found that the 'forecasting of economic benefits is generally not accurate' and that 'over half of the scheme models have under-predicted traffic volumes on the old route and [two-thirds] under-predicted by more than 25%'."

Here is what I sent to the minister from the Campaign for Better Transport website:"I have just seen a report that confirms what has been obvious for a while - the Highways Agency's forecasts are inaccurate. The failure to update their modeling means that we are getting projects that are not the best for local people or the planet. I ask that there is a moratorium on major road building until more accurate modeling has been carried out."

Please think about going here to also send a message.

21 Jan 2010

Time for action: 'Stroud Bus Station' long overdue

Nine out of ten bus users in Stroud say they have had enough of getting cold and wet while they wait for a bus in the town. Well done to the Town Council for doing this research - see here - for so long we have been told we will get a new bus station and that the current arrangements at Merrywalks are 'temporary' - however this last summer a final nail in the coffin of a new bus station was delivered - see here.

The Town have taken the initiative and undertaken this survey after improvement of bus facilities in the town was identified as a top priority for local people - around 250 people took part in the survey which also showed strong support for better signposting to local facilities, improved cleanliness, more seating, a payphone and a new clock. There were also widespread calls for the provision of a cafe and waiting room. I would echo all that - the lack of any decent shelter and no coffee being the worst aspects for me!!

The Town Council has already begun a number of preliminarily discussions and had several meetings - they have also set aside £17,500 over three years towards the cost of improvements, with the shelters being the top priority. It will be seeking support from the district and county councils to implement the priorities identified by local people. See here a history of the Stroud buses on this blog.

20 Jan 2010

Dirty gold win plus pesticides, GM and bees

I've covered gold mining before on this blog (see post Blood Diamond, blood coltan, blood gold) - it is not a good picture - but here is some good news - A landmark ban in Hungary on the use of cyanide in mining looks set to make huge improvements in public health. The change follows a 10 year campaign by the Hungarian Green party along with many other organisations. Now the country's neighbours need to follow her lead...

Along with the nuclear industry, gold mining is one of the world's dirtiest industries that is creating a multi-billion-pound toxic time-bomb. The gold is extracted using cyanide leaching and has already led to vast tracts of the developing world being laid to waste.

See Ecologist article here. See October 2005 Glos Green party news release here with more background info.

The Ecologist also has some other great stories worth a read like:

Was 2009 the year the world turned against GM? See here.

Update on pesticide campaign: UK court refuses to overturn appeal decision despite accusations it was ignoring evidence presented by the long-time pesticide campaigner
. Pesticide campaigner Georgina Downs is taking her case against the UK government to the European courts after failing to get a previous victory upheld by the Supreme Court.See here. You can also see more about Georgina's amazing campaign and the extraordinary failures of Government to protect citizens - see here.

Loss of forage biggest long-term threat to bees. Pesticides do not appear to be the main problem in this case although they clearly play a part - see here.

Toothless Tory 'ombudsman' won't solve supermarket problem. It's high time we had a supermarket ombudsman, but it needs to be proactive and powerful, says Caroline Lucas - See here.

19 Jan 2010

Bloggers unite for Haiti

Bloggers Unite for Haiti is today January 19 - the idea is to share information about this disaster and how people around the world can provide aid to ongoing relief efforts.The purpose of Bloggers Unite for Haiti is to encourage bloggers to posts about ways to donate to help the relief efforts in Haiti. They also encourage posts about current conditions in Haiti or to share information about this tragic event with readers around the world.

Well many of us have seen the disturbing images and heard some of the stories coming out of Haiti - the worst earthquake in 200 years - it has led to countless deaths and tragedies.
Haiti's infrastructure and communications have been shattered.

The London-based Haiti Support Group can be found here with suggestions to donate money. It is also worth noting the international charity RedR is supporting aid agencies, who are deploying emergency teams in response. Also see the Oxfam link here. Mind beware of internet scams - the FBI have issued a warning regarding the Haiti earthquake - see here.

The Green party of the United States is urging President Obama to make peace, political self-determination, and economic self-sufficiency part of US relief efforts for Haiti - see here.
"We hope President Obama sees this sad occasion as a chance to initiate a new era of relations with Haiti, one based on cooperation, respect, and non-intervention. It should begin with a massive and green rebuilding effort that promotes Haiti's political self-determination and economic self-sufficiency. If President Obama's post-earthquake aid plan for Haiti puts an end to a century of exploitation for cheap labor, brutal human rights abuses by US-backed regimes, colonial corruption and graft, and political bullying by the US, he'll be remembered for having helped the Haitian people emerge from two disasters -- the earthquake itself and Haiti's status as the poorest nation in the western hemisphere."
Rosa Clemente, 2008 Green nominee for Vice President of the United States

"The decision on Friday, January 15, to grant Temporary Protected Status to Haitians residing in the US before January 12 was long overdue. We're glad the Obama Administration announced that deportations of undocumented Haitians in the US will cease and that Haitians will be allowed access to employment opportunities so they can support their families."
Betty Davis, co-chair of the Green Party Black Caucus.
Haiti has seen improvements in recent years - it is shattering to see these swept away. Yet seeing the Haitian people's courage and faith in the midst of catastrophe is inspiring. Their is hope that after this earthquake something good can come. It is also inspiring to see thousands of others writing similar posts to this in an effort to spread the cry for help as far and wide as possible. There can be few who have not heard about this disaster.

Tesco must come clean on their biofuels

Tesco have previously admitted using Palm oil in their biofuels - as this blog has noted before this is associated with a number of serious problems including large scale deforestation, adding to climate change and human rights abuses in Indonesia.

Tesco have said they ask their suppliers to provide a sustainability statement however apparently despite requests for a copy of this it has never been forthcoming.

Kevin Lister, a Nailsworth campaigner has been seeking answers - can Tesco now demonstrate responsibly sourced biofuels? Will it remove it from other products? See his latest letter to Tesco here, a letter to The Times here and a link the recent documentary on the Community Channel, 'Lost in Palm Oil'.

18 Jan 2010

Scrutiny: Joint Use sports centres, energy efficiency and disabled facilities grants

Last week I had a couple of Scrutiny meetings - one on financing climate change measures - well our report is nearly out so I wont cover that here - the other was the evening Performance Overview and Scrutiny Committee and a look at the budget.

Photo: Ebley Mill viewed through trees from Randwick

Well again I can't cover all that here but several key issues I raised are covered below. I also sought information on the savings from posts not being filled - this can have a huge impact on remaining staff workloads and I am already aware that some have very high workloads. Many other issues were covered including news that Iceland money may not come back although the Cabinet member remains 'cautiously optimistic'.

Money for household energy efficiency and climate change

I made the point that this was welcomed as one of the only growth areas however it is small fry - just £100,000 next year with no more for the next 5 years! How can this possibly tackle the huge and growing problem of fuel poverty.

Many in the chamber were sympathetic but no more money available. I hope when the initial recommendations of the Scrutiny inquiry come to light we will be able to tackle this issue more. We must find a way forward - indeed had a useful discussion last week about what the blocks are to borrowing money to pay for such measures - pretty well none was the answer - in my view we need to move towards developing the Council's own renewable energy through an ESCo - borrowing then in some years we would have an income stream. It makes economic, environmental and moral sense......

Disabled facilities grants

The situation is getting worse - 12 to 15 month waiting lists for disabled people and longer waits forecast. This is not acceptable - nobody in the chamber was happy about it. SDC already work in partnership with Occupational Therapists, but I asked whether more could be done? It was a gloomy picture as even with more money the contractor could not take on more work. I still think we need to look at alternatives and will be asking more re this.

Joint Use centres to close?

On 30th November Stroud District Council issued a press release. In it the Council's Deputy Leader, Councillor Keith Pearson, is quoted as saying: "It is regrettable that we have to look at reducing the number of sports centres we manage but the bare facts show that not enough people use them. We have to be responsible with how we spend taxpayers' money and councils are under more and more pressure to show value for money".

At the 10 December 2009 Cabinet meeting. Agenda Item 10 titled, 'The General Fund Revenue Budget 2010/2011' states in paragraph 6 said: “This efficiency process ( the Medium Term Financial Plan) has included a decision to hand back two joint use sites namely Vale of Berkeley College, Nailsworth Primary School and Wotton Pool, the savings from which will be realised in the 2011/2012 budget”.

But now a consultation has been launched and we are having a special cabinet meeting on 28th Jan to discuss this ‘consultation’. I asked about why can we not have greater clarity of process here? It would appear that these proposals just came out of nowhere with no consultation? How fair is it to cut service from 3 centres without discussing it fully with local people?

As I have noted before there appears to be no strategic plan for leisure services (see here). This appears to be just cost-cutting without proper consideration. It is claimed that services are not providing ‘value’ so plans are made to cut the service rather than evaluating what value is and how we might seek it. This is not in my view the way to go about business. However I am encouraged that a more proper consultation has now been launched - however it still looks likely to lead to closure of some or all of the six joint use centres.

I recognise savings need to be made but as the Mayor of Nailsworth, Norman Kay points out in his report looking specifically at the centre in Nailsworth: "A 'reasonable' local authority would be expected to use such evidence, together with an assessment of resources available, to devise a comprehensive vision and plan for the Leisure Service, which addresses these considerations within the plan...SDC may, having done this, still decide on withdrawing from the NRC, but importantly, the decision would be based on evidence which could be used to demonstrate the comprehensiveness and efficiency of the service provided by reference to demonstrable need and resources...Financial savings may still be made, but the absence of a review of the Leisure Service, and the Council's apparent interpretation of an 'efficient' service as being entirely in financial terms, has appeared to rule out any meaningful discussions of other options....Service operation is limited from the information on the Council's website. It seems to have been underpublicised for some time. It is sensible for a Leisure Service to promote and encourage use. It is good practice for any public service to encourage participation through clear and easy ways to join, access, shape and influence the service....Service Delivery - Usage and Capacity. No evidence was put before Cabinet members to show what (if any) information the Council considered regarding usage patterns, or whether any other evidence was drawn on to guide the decision on withdrawing from the provision of the service at the NRC....Satisfaction with the service and links with other services/partners. There is no information on the satisfaction of users and ways in which the NRC facilities have been promoted to potential users, through for example, corporate membership for local employers; or how the Council is assisting/enabling the National Health Service through the PCT to obtain maximum benefit for its clients....The absence of a strategic plan or a development plan for the Leisure service, based on an assessment of need and a contemporaneous review of the service, completely hinders the Council being able to describe how its plans will meet the needs of, and have due regard for, the exercise and sports needs of those who live and work in Nailsworth."

I understand a large report will soon be available to those on request that hopefully will answer some of the concerns re lack of strategy. I await with interest.

Incinerator talk on 4th Feb

Thursday 4th February will see a public meeting looking at the possible dangers posed by waste incineration and the safer alternatives. It will be held at King's Stanley Village Hall, Broad St., King's Stanley, Nr. Stroud, GL10 3HZ from 7.30 p.m. to 9.30 p.m (doors open at 7.00 p.m.).

Photo: It was such a surprise to see the world back to normal again after all that white!

The presentation will be given by Dr. Paul Connett, Professor of Chemistry, St Lawrence University, New York. Dr. Connett has researched waste management issues for over 14 years (specialising in the dangers posed by incineration and in the safer and more sustainable non-burn alternatives). He is a well-know scientist, and is currently on a lecture tour in Italy so we are very fortunate to have him in the District. Apparently Dr Connett's "Zero Waste and Sustainability" talk to the UN Division on Sustainable Development on 12th Jan. 2010 was so successful that they now want to work further with him.

The talk will cover how waste incineration affects your health, wealth and environment and look at the environmentally friendly, cost effective, non-toxic alternatives. Dr. Connett will bring examples about how different places in the world are successfully dealing with their waste without incineration, and there will be the opportunity to ask him questions and learn from his vast experience and knowledge. Download poster here.

Nuclear: how to take part in consultations

Much happening locally re nuke stuff - first though petition to sign at: http://petitions.number10.gov.uk/NuclearNo/

I should also point to the Stop Hinkley website here with news, actions and more plus see the local site re Oldbury here - indeed the photo is a mock up from that site about how it could look with the planned cooling towers.

Well various consultations are going on at the moment, but I have to say much of the process baffles me.

The Government has launched consultations on its Draft National Policy Statements on Energy Infrastructure – including one on nuclear power – and on the Proposed Regulatory Justification decisions on new nuclear power stations. Both consultations close on 22nd February 2010. The draft National Policy Statements are also subject to Parliamentary scrutiny. For more information see: www.nuclear-nps-events.info/home.aspx

The Energy and Climate Change Committee has already called for written evidence to help it determine whether the energy NPSs are fit for purpose - but they wont take account of submissions made before Friday January 15th!! Too late for that then.

However oral hearings have started with many having already given evidence: the Royal Town Planning Institute, Town and Country Planning Association, Greenpeace, Friends of the Earth and WWF. The Department of Energy and Climate Change has also arrange meetings around the country to consult - but these have faced a barrage of criticism for the way they have been organised.

There is also a huge amount of material to read in order to understand what is being proposed. Greenpeace has calculated that the average concerned individual living near one of the ten proposed nuclear sites would need to read more pages than War and Peace – and that is just to respond to the Nuclear NPS. This cannot be considered a real consultation but then we know the whole process is flawed in so many ways - see previous comments on nuke consultation here.

The excellent No2 Nuclear Power website notes Hugh Ellis, Chief Planner at the Town and County Planning Association told MPs on the Select Committee that the government has failed to engage with the public on the NPSs. He said: “It is creating an environment of suspicion”.

Help with consultations

The Nuclear Free Local Authorities have published two briefings – one on the NPS consultation and one on the Justification consultation. Stop Hinkley also have excellent templates - see here. I am starting to put my thoughts together......it is important.....

Under the Planning Act 2008 the Nuclear NPS consultation is basically the last chance to challenge the principle that new nuclear reactors should be built, and that these reactors should be permitted to generate nuclear waste. It looks likely that, as things stand at the moment, the Infrastructure Planning Commission (IPC) will be simply told that the strategic question of whether nuclear waste should be disposed of in a geological repository has already been decided and that any planning application for a geological disposal facility only needs to be examined with regard to local planning issues. This is outrageous.

Locally we have seen Northavon MP Steve Webb meet with representatives from the IPC, which is the new body that will decide on any future nuclear developments. He is quoted saying: "After my discussions with the Infrastructure Planning Commission it has become clear to me that the process of consultation over a new nuclear power plant risks baffling us all. There are pre-application consultations, exhibitions and debates, preliminary public meetings and full public hearings, all over a period of more than two years. We have to give our views to the nuclear power company, to the council, to the Government and to the Infrastructure Planning Commission. It is vital that there is real clarity so that people who feel strongly about these issues know when and how they can have their say."

At the moment people living near the Oldbury site are being encouraged to respond to the Department for Energy and Climate Change's consultation on the National Policy Statement for Energy Infrastructure as mentioned above. It was this document which listed Oldbury as a preferred site and it is this consultation that will guide the IPC when it makes its decisions.

However separate to the government's consultation, E.ON, the energy company that wants to build a new station at Oldbury, will also be carrying out its own consultation with residents, but this is not expected until the end of 2011.

Meanwhile Stroud's David Drew MP - an advocate and campaigner for nuclear - has also expressed concerns re the NPS process. He has signed an Early Day Motion (EDM 545) last week that notes concern "that the current scrutiny process does not appear to adhere fully to the Government's commitments made earlier this year during debate on the Planning Bill; regrets that the Energy and Climate Change Select Committee's simultaneous scrutiny of all five NPSs has been compressed into an inordinately limited timescale that overlaps with the public consultation period.... and calls on the Government to reconsider whether the current
process provides the full and proper parliamentary scrutiny process to which such crucial documents should be subjected."

Lastly I came across this article which I enjoyed by Johathan Porritt from December saying it is time to renew the fight against nuclear - see here. In the article he posed a number of questions - here are some of them:

Who is going to hold to account politicians and industry leaders for whom secrecy remains the default mindset?

Who is going to expose the near-fraudulent accounting practices endemic within the nuclear industry that continue to blind people to the true economic costs and penalties involved in nuclear power?

Who is going to interrogate the philosophical and moral implications of one generation imposing on the next a set of problems and security hazards for which they themselves have absolutely no solution?

And who is going to take on those sincere but utterly misguided environmentalists who’ve “gone nuclear” over the last few years because they feel there’s no alternative?

Nuke design consultation

Lastly I have just been contacted by the Environment Agency who are currently involved in the Generic Design Assessment process (a process which has lasted 3 years) - during which they have examined the proposed two reactor designs from an environmental perspective. They plan to complete their assessment and hope to consult on findings - I have been invited to one of their planned seminars but at this point am unsure about the value of going along. We'll see but do please contact me if anyone reading this is interested.

17 Jan 2010

Hospital cleaners are worth more than elite city bankers

Hospital cleaners are worth more to society than elite City bankers, according to new analysis from the New Economics Foundation (nef). This could be a bit of nonsense - or at least I thought that until I looking more closely - a very refreshing way to look at this issue which comes to conclusions that I am sure many agree - how for example can it be right that we entrust our most important 'resource' - the next generation - with some of the least well paid people in the country?

Photo: money pushed into logs for luck

The new report, A Bit Rich?, uses new quantification techniques to calculate the value created for society by a range of different professions. Here's what nef write: "For each, the authors measured the conventional economic returns, such as the number of jobs created, as well as key environmental impacts, including climate change effects, and social impacts, for example contribution to individual or community well-being. Weighing up the positive and negative economic, environmental and social impacts produced an overall result for each occupation. The results revealed that the more poorly paid jobs - hospital cleaners, recycling workers and childcare professionals - were more valuable to society than the highly paid jobs, high-earning City bankers, advertising executives and accountants helping the most wealthy individuals and companies avoid tax."

The research highlights the fact that, at the moment, salaries are a very poor indicator of the contribution a job makes to society and that some of the most valuable roles are the least well-paid. nef believes that we need a pay structure which recognises all aspects of value and rewards those jobs that create most benefit to society, rather than rewarding work which generates profit at the expense of society and the environment."

Many national papers picked up the story - see for example The Guardian here which picked out that the report challenged the notion that high pay did not matter as long as poverty was eradicated. The report showed how high pay is often generated by businesses that destroy other parts of the economy or fail to pay the full costs of their activities.

The report said tax accountants were the most destructive, laying waste to £47 of value for every £1 they created. Elite City bankers (earning £1m plus bonuses) destroy £7 of value for every £1 they create and advertising executives wreck £11 of value for every £1 they are paid. On the other hand, the report judged that waste-recycling workers generated £12 for every £1 spent on their wages. Childcare workers create between £7 and £9.50 of value for every £1 of pay and hospital cleaners create more than £10 in value for every £1 they receive in pay.

16 Jan 2010

Guest Blog: Radioactive Shipwrecks in Italian Waters

Well I am delighted to be able to offer this piece regarding the radioactive shipwrecks in Italian waters.

Photo: The sea of Cetraro, Calabria, south of Italy

It is by local campaigner and author, Angela Paine - originally for The Guardian but was not printed so appeared on her blog that will soon be disappearing so Ruscombe Green readers will now have this shocking story....

Radioactive Shipwrecks in Italian Waters

On 25th October 2009, twenty thousand people marched in Amantea, in the province of Cosenza, Calabria, southern Italy, in protest against the Calabrian Mafia (’ndragheta), who they say have been deliberately sinking ships carrying toxic and radioactive wastes along their coastline.

During the preceding week, trade union representatives from Alto Tirreno, a Region in north Calabria, petitioned the Rome government to deal with these toxic and radioactive shipwrecks. They met with little success.

The Quotidiano della Calabria newspaper collected more than thirty thousand signatures protesting the government’s inertia. The protestors demanded the government to clean up the seabed around Cetraro, Vibo and Capo Bruzzano, (near Brancaleone) the sites of known shipwrecks with radioactive and toxic cargoes. They also demanded the government search for other shipwrecks with radioactive and toxic cargoes, but the ’ndragheta are understood to be blocking investigations in order to prevent more shipwrecks being found.

The radioactive shipwrecks have unleashed a political storm in Calabria. Fisheries and tourism are the two major industries of Calabria, so the contamination of fish and the reduction of tourism threaten the livelihoods of many in this poor Italian region. Interestingly, the seven hundred people killed by the ’ndragheta between 1985 and 1992, the hundreds of ’ndragheta kidnappings, and the scores of ’ndragheta scandals involving most Calabrian politicians, appear to have caused less anger than the alleged radioactive shipwrecks, as this is the first time Calabrians have raised their voices en masse against ’ndragheta.

It is feared that the sinking of ships has gone on for many years, but the issue came to a head on the 12th October, when a wreck was discovered 14 miles off the coast of Cetraro, near Amantea, Calabria. On October 20, an ’ndragheta boss, Francesco Fonti, confessed in an interview published by L’Espresso magazine that he had sunk the Cunski exactly where the wreck was found and that its cargo was radioactive waste. He told L’Espresso that he took orders from multinational corporations to dispose of radioactive waste sent to him in ships.

The Italian government has been aware of shipwrecks containing deadly cargos around its southern coasts since 1994, when Legambiente, an Italian environmental organisation, started an inquest in Reggio Calabria. According to Lloyd’s Shipping Register, 39 ships were sunk in the Ionian sea between 1979 and 1995. Fonti has stated 30 were sunk by the local ’ndragheta.

The inquest first focussed on the ship, Rigel, which sank on 21 September 1987, 20 miles from Capo Spartivento, in the municipality of Brancaleone, near Reggio Calabria. It was believed that the captain, Giorgio Comerio, a go-between for arms dealers, mine manufacturers, and various ‘ndragheta clans, played a pivotal role in the nuclear waste dumping business. This ship was probably carrying radioactive waste, as raised radioactivity levels were found in the sea near the wreck.

The Marco Polo, which sank in the Straits of Sicily between Calabria and Sicily, was carrying a cargo of containers, some of which were found in 1994 along the coast of Campania, the region to the north of Calabria. Scientists found increased levels of radioactive thorium 234 in environmental samples. Presumably the ship was carrying radioactive waste when it sank. The Koraline sank near Ustica, a small island, 53 kilometres north of Capo Gallo, Sicily. Its containers were highly contaminated with thorium.

After months of investigation, the Legambiente inquest began to realise the extent of the contamination of the south Italian coast. However as the evidence of radioactive waste dumping mounted, the Environment Ministry brought the inquest to an abrupt halt and refused to allow the authorities in Reggio Calabria to investigate the ships sunk near Capo Spartivento.

The inquest at Reggio Calabria found contracts in connection with some of the sunken ships. It appears that some European governments may have sent radioactive waste to ’ndragheta clans through intermediaries. The contracts stated that waste should be inserted into steel tubes, inside steel containers with sonar systems, so that they could be found if necessary in the future. The containers were to be deposited 50-80 metres deep in the sea or buried deep on land. The ’ndragheta clans appeared to have decided to avoid all this work and simply sink the ships in the Mediterranean, with the ship-owners subsequently claiming the insurance.

Fonti told L’Espresso “For years, no-one wanted to listen to what I had to say in court. I always admitted that I was involved in dumping this waste in shipwrecks, both toxic and radioactive. I told them where to find the shipwrecks along the coast of Cetraro, and indeed on 12th September, the Calabria Region government ... found one of the ships, the Cunski, exactly where I told them to look.”

A robot operated mini submarine was sent down to photograph the wreck and its cargo. The video showed the old ship with a hole in its hull, through which several barrels could be seen, one of which was empty.

Francesco Fonti explained to L’Espresso how he sank three ships, including the Cunski in 1992. “I put dynamite inside a big lump of concrete on board the ships with a long fuse, then I blew them up. It was easy." He and members of his ’ndragheta clan also sank the Yvonne A at Maratea in the Gulf of Policastro, and the Voriais Sporadais at Melito Porto Salvo near Reggio di Calabria. All three ships were carrying toxic and radioactive cargoes. Fonti said that ’ndragheta had carried out these sinkings for the arms dealer, Ignazio Messina. He added “I sank 3 ships but I know from ’ndragheta bosses that at least 3 other ships were sunk between Scilla and Caribdes, another one near Tropea and others near Crotone. I can’t remember exactly where they sunk the others.”

Fonti said that he worked for various Italian politicians, including De Stefano, Dc Ciriaco de Mita and Riccardo Misasi. Misasi would tell him whether to dump the waste on land or at sea, and Dc Ciriaco de Mita asked him to dispose of waste for the state. “We could get between 4 and 20 billion lire for dumping a load. The money was deposited in a Swiss Bank in Lugano, or in a bank in Cyprus, Malta, Vaduz or Singapore. We did it all through the banker Valentino Foti.” These politicians deny involvement, but the absences of investigation and media coverage are notable.

Although it is tempting to point a finger at the Mafia, Camorra and ’ndrageta in Italy, these perform just the dirty end of a business that originates in other parts of Italy, Northern Europe and other parts of the world. For example, some of these ships were carrying waste for international arms dealers who were paid for the disposal of radioactive waste and who collected money fraudulently from insurance companies when the ships sank. Fonti named some of the arms dealers, including Saud Omar Mugne from Somalia, but Fonti has not yet revealed the origin of all the waste, perhaps because he does not know. He added that ’ndragheta stopped dumping toxic and radioactive waste off the coast of Italy several years ago and started sending ships to Africa, mainly to the coast of Somalia.

Of course, Fonti may not be a credible witness since he is a member of ’ndragheta, under house arrest for drug trafficking offences. But he is not the only person to indicate a link between the radioactive waste business and illegal arms dealing. The Italian journalist, Ilaria Alpi, discovered a link between toxic waste dumping by the Mafia and arms traffic in Somalia. She was killed in March 1994 in Somalia. Her death certificate has disappeared, but a photocopy was found on the property of the arms dealer Saud Omar Mugne. He is suspected of buying and selling arms between East Europe, Italy and Africa. According to Fonti and Ilaria Alpi, he was also involved in the toxic and radioactive waste disposal business. Several secret service operatives from various countries, who were trying to get to the bottom of this affair, were also killed in mysterious circumstances.

The inquest started by Legambiente in 1994 discovered a web of international financiers from big banks involved in a money-laundering programme called the “Roll Programme.” Fonti also points to the involvement of international financiers in the toxic and radioactive waste disposal business, with its links to the arms trade.

Silvestro Greco, a Calabrian Environment Councillor, who attended an emergency meeting at the Environment Ministry in Rome on 22nd October, said the shipwreck discovery should not just be considered a problem for Calabria. ‘‘There are perhaps another 30 ships still missing that were used to hide toxic, harmful and radioactive waste,’’ he said. ‘‘This pollution is a problem for all areas, not just those along the coast, because illegal trafficking in waste knows no international boundaries’’. He pointed out that ‘‘the entire Mediterranean, from the Adriatic Sea to the Tyrrhenian Sea, and from the Straits of Sicily to the Aegean Sea’’ was damaged by the sinking of toxic waste ships. ‘‘Cleaning and removing the load will be particularly complex in terms of financing, given that a vast area is involved,’’ Greco added. ‘‘In our opinion, the European Union should get involved, as well as the Italian government”.

Mario Pirillo, a Calabrian Member of the European Parliament, together with seven other MEPs, filed an official request with the European Commission on Tuesday asking for its assistance. The request pointed out that Italian investigators believed the Cunski was sunk by an international criminal network involved in Europe-wide illegal waste disposal. It is important to recall that Italy only ever had one small nuclear power station. So though some of the radioactive waste in these shipwrecks may have originated in Italy, most almost certainly did not.

Then suddenly, on the 29th Oct, the environment minister, Stefania Prestagiacomo, held a press conference in Rome to announce that the shipwreck found at Cetraro was not a ship carrying a cargo of radioactive waste. It was the Catania, a passenger ship, which sank in 1917. The attorney Grasso then announced that the inquest into the Cetraro shipwreck was closed.

This, however, was not the end of the story. L’Espresso, once again, delving into the matter, interviewed Pippo Arena, the pilot of the remotely operated vehicle. He said that when he inspected the shipwreck near Cetraro in September, he saw two hulls and they were full of barrels. “Full of what I don’t know, but full” he said. This is in sharp contrast with the results of the other inspection, carried out from the ship, Mare Oceano, also off the coast of Cetraro. The shipwreck Catania that they found here had empty hulls. The two videos showed shipwrecks of different sizes, and the coordinates of the first shipwreck and those of the Catania demonstrated that they were about three and a half miles from each other. It was beginning to look as if there were more than one wreck off the coast of Cetraro.

This was born out by evidence recently leaked from the unpublished minutes of a meeting in the Italian parliament on 24th January 2006, to discuss the iniquitous waste recycling business. It emerged from this document that there were three shipwrecks off the coast of Cetraro, not one. None of the measurements of the three ships corresponds to the measurements of the Catania, the wreck found by the Mare Oceano. At the time, the MP Franco Greco told the commission that the fishermen of the area had found some barrels in the sea. So many questions have been raised that the WWF has entered the fray:

“There are inconsistencies between the declarations of the Environment Minister and the Region of Calabria and the report of the pilot of the ROV, who said that the two hulls of the boat during the first inspection were full whereas the Dda of Catanzaro talked about one ship with one empty hull,” a WWF spokesperson said.

So the WWF, which on the 2nd of November already officially requested a public comparison of the two inspections, repeated their request to Environment Minister Stefania Prestigiacomo and the head of the national antimafia organisation Piero Grasso. They asked to be allowed to choose experts to compare the two videos made by the ROV. They also want the coordinates to be taken into consideration, and the technical details of the ships that were found. The Environment Minister responded by putting the two videos on the website “for complete information, transparency and so that the public can make comparisons.”

Clearly the mystery surrounding the toxic and radioactive shipwrecks off the coast of Calabria remains. The Italian Government, despite continued calls from the Green Party and many other MPs to get to the bottom of it, appear to be dragging their feet. But since there are clear indications that the waste business is international, Italy should not be left to deal with this problem on her own. The European Union should be involved, both to provide funding and expertise.

Notes:
(URLs as of 11 Nov 2009) http://unoenessuno.blogspot.com/2009/10/blu-notte-navi-perdere.html This blog talks about the book The Lost Ships. Police detective Commander Natale de Grazia died suddenly while investigating shipwrecks carrying nuclear and toxic waste. There is a picture of the red ship, Jolly Rosso, that landed on the beach. It had a cargo of nuclear waste, which was spirited away. The ship was broken up and taken away in lorries. No one knows where the nuclear waste went, but a quarry near the beach is now radioactive. http://current.com/items/90187321_le-navi-dei-veleni.htm This discusses 30 ships that disappeared. Some were found and observed to have increased levels radioactivity near them, but there is no political will to remove their cargoes. 2009/10/20 http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=qfvu_r0FPQ0&feature=related A spokesperson for the Italian environmental organisation, Legambiente, talks about the international traffic in nuclear and toxic waste. Many countries pay to get rid of their waste, which ends up being dumped by ’ndrangheta (the southern Italian equivalent of the Mafia) 2009/10/20 http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ZT90O1D7p5s&feature=related This shows an interview with the former ’ndrangheta boss, Francesco Fonti, who confessed that he blew up three old ships carrying toxic and radioactive wastes, off the coast of Italy. He told the authorities exactly where to find them, and they found one, where he said. It had a cargo of radioactive waste. The Government sent down a mini submarine to take photos of it but don’t want to do anything about it. http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=NXSJHjMkx8I This shows local fishermen protesting about the damage to their livelihoods. They ask how can we live when the fish are radioactive and tourists will not want to come to our beaches again. http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=WxhtBxlGHYo&feature=related This shows the people in charge of the inquest, and the two journalists who were beginning to uncover the link beween the illegal sale of arms and radioactive and toxic waste dumping in Somalia before they were murdered. http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Tj3lbBjz1BM&NR=1 http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=15ks8HRRJ5s&feature=related These show the shipwreck found fourteen miles off the coast of Calabria, five hundred metres deep. There are holes in the side of the ship and you can see some of the barrels of radioactive cargo, one of which is empty. Calabria Region hasn’t got the money or the expertise to do anything about it. See here video-footage of a shipwreck 12 miles from Molfetta with a highly toxic cargo. See here. www.ANSA.it The main Italian press agency See here. Public enquiry on waste recycling for the Basilicata Region. See here. Parliamentary Request by the foreign minister, the environment minister and the justice minister for an enquiry into the international network of toxic and radioactive waste traffic. See here. Public enquiry into the illegal disposal of toxic and radioactive waste. Riccardo Bocca; "Naufragio radioattivo" (Radioactive Shipwreck); L’Espresso, 9 September 2004, page.34 onwards. Riccardo Bocca; Indagini Radioattive - colloquio con Paolo Russo (Radioactive Enquiry – interview with Paolo Russo); L’Espresso, 16 September 2004, page.76 onwards. Riccardo Bocca; Nella memoria si è aperta una falla - colloquio con Gianfranco Messina (There seems to be a crevasse opening up in the collective memory – interview with Gianfranco Messina.) L’Espresso, 23 September 2004, pag.76 onwards . See here. Toxic ships. The pilot of the robot operated submarine raises doubts about the second film. So the environment minister puts both films on the website. See here. Navi al veleno, buone nuove a Cetraro (Poison Ships, good news at Cetraro) by Paolo Poggio ROMA 29/10/09 - 20:13 See here. WWF asks for a new enquiry